[Hood's Path]

Well with 11 people, you only get so many chances to do it right.

[Galain]

Hood, on 05 May 2010 - 04:27 PM, said:

You're saying that my vote is somehow attached to other votes simply for being first on the same target. There's no logic in that, you're trying to draw an erroneous conclusion based on facts. I could just as easily say that Korbas is scum looking for a train and Barghast and Eloth followed him on. Or Barghast is scum and followed Korbas on. Or Eloth is scum and followed one of them on, or maybe one of them is just scum and wanted to jump on a train.

Instead, you're voting me, and it smells a LOT like OMGUS, wrapped in a pretty bow.

Of course there is logic to that. Barghast, Eloth and Korbas in all likelihood all x-posted. Now, for some reason three people chose to follow a vote who's sole basis was that the target in question was drunk last night. It makes no sense that such a train would ever take off, let alone get three votes within a couple of minutes of each other. Ergo, there must've been some other reason for them to vote and the most logical is that one or two of them chose to follow their master; you.

You're kicking hard at OMGUS thing, but by the end of the day you insist on your vote on me because "no one post while drunk if their inno"

[Path-Shaper]

It is Day 1. 30 minutes remain.

11 players are alive
Ampelas,Barghast,D'riss,Eloth,Fener,Galain,Hood's Path,Korbas,Liosan,Mockra,Osseric

6 votes to lynch. 6 votes to go to night


3 votes Galain (Hood's Path, Korbas, Barghast)
3 votes Hood's Path (Galain, D'riss, Liosan)
1 Vote Korbas (Eloth)

Not voted
Ampelas,Fener,Mockra,Osseric


edit - lol, quote fail. Nothing to see here!

This post has been edited by Path-Shaper: 05 May 2010 - 04:54 PM

[Barghast]

Remove Vote
Vote Hoods Path

I think Eloth is most likely a symp freaking out (or a partner, but that is doubtful), and the only one I can really believe he is following is HP. So, the change in votes.

[Hood's Path]

Well, when I come up inno, don't sit around and start and ponder if I'm possibly a symp for someone or some other ridiculous case. You're all voting me for being a leader, obviously.

[Path-Shaper]

It is Day 1. 24 minutes remain.

11 players are alive
Ampelas,Barghast,D'riss,Eloth,Fener,Galain,Hood's Path,Korbas,Liosan,Mockra,Osseric

6 votes to lynch. 6 votes to go to night


2 votes Galain (Hood's Path, Korbas)
4 votes Hood's Path (Galain, D'riss, Liosan, Barghast)
1 Vote Korbas (Eloth)

Not voted
Ampelas,Fener,Mockra,Osseric

[Barghast]

Remove Vote

[Ampelas]

I will admit on my catching up that Galain's drunk post did give me an uneasy feeling, since I never trust what looks to be drunken posting at face value (unless we're playing drunken speed mafia, we should do that again sometime ). That said the whole crossposting thing set off alarm bells.

HP's case wasn't exactly strong and Galain hadn't really said anything that might be incriminating, so I felt any of the three (but especially Korbas for not really putting in any reasoning) could easily have been scum hopping onto what looked like an easy train. Given our propensity for lynching drunk posters combined with our Day one fickleness, if those votes hadn't crossposted, any one of them could have been the beginning of the end for galain. So any of the three could easily be scum, be it killer or symp. That said, I highly doubt scum would organise a crosspost like that, this early in the game it's sure to draw a lot of attention. So at most one scum out of those three.

Personally I'd like to vote for one of the three crossposting people, either Korbas for lack of reasoning or Eloth for his panicy looking remove.

[Liosan]

So say HP is right and that he is inno. And Eloth is a symp to his master. Wouldn't his changing vote mean that maybe one of the people that he xposted with is his master and not HP?

[Path-Shaper]

It is Day 1. 16 minutes remain.

11 players are alive
Ampelas,Barghast,D'riss,Eloth,Fener,Galain,Hood's Path,Korbas,Liosan,Mockra,Osseric

6 votes to lynch. 6 votes to go to night


2 votes Galain (Hood's Path, Korbas)
3 votes Hood's Path (Galain, D'riss, Liosan)
1 Vote Korbas (Eloth)

Not voted
Ampelas,Barghast,Fener,Mockra,Osseric

[Hood's Path]

Well figure it out, y'all. It's going to be a rush anyway at this point.

Remove vote
Vote Eloth

[Ampelas]

As for Galain vs HP, I'm siding more with Galain on this one. I'm not sure how three people voting for Galain at the same time make him more scummy, or that he is overreacting. While I dont trust drunk posts I dont think they alone merit a lynch either and HP's vote still seems mainly based around that fact.

[Hood's Path]

Liosan, on 05 May 2010 - 05:02 PM, said:

So say HP is right and that he is inno. And Eloth is a symp to his master. Wouldn't his changing vote mean that maybe one of the people that he xposted with is his master and not HP?

Well that would make it Barghast then, unless Eloth left his vote on Korbas just to signal him.

[Ampelas]

Liosan, on 05 May 2010 - 05:02 PM, said:

So say HP is right and that he is inno. And Eloth is a symp to his master. Wouldn't his changing vote mean that maybe one of the people that he xposted with is his master and not HP?

This could also be true. As I said, I highly doubt there's more than one killer out of Bargy, Korbas and Eloth, but there could be more than one scum.

[Osseric]

well, The fact that the galain train amped up then just smashed to a halt makes me think something is up with galain as it shouldn't be that hard to get a day 1 lynch. Personally I would like to see Eloth go. His vote was very scummy.

whats the count at now?

I would vote HP for a lynch... btu I think he is probably telling the truth about being inno.

[Liosan]

Barghast. Why did you remove your vote? Are you trying to avoid a day one lynch because you look like a likely canidate as Korbas master?

[Ampelas]

Barghast, on 05 May 2010 - 04:57 PM, said:

Remove Vote

Does anyone else think this is wierd? Change in votes, then a remove with no explanation. Specially so late in the day.

[Osseric]

Barghast, on 05 May 2010 - 04:57 PM, said:

Remove Vote

whats up with this???

[Osseric]

meh, X post.

[Liosan]

I'm okay moving to Eloth though I think that he is most likely a symp.