[Path-Shaper]

Kalse, on 25 January 2010 - 08:28 PM, said:

I am thinking Kill Gamelon instead.. he is pretty much CI'd on thread. I won't change my provisional until I hear from you. Also I didn't change my order... the mayor wouldn't go into effect till day 7 and I don't think the game will go on that long, so kind of a waste.

Looks like The Dude finally realized Gamelon can't be kept alive.

[Path-Shaper]

Osseric, on 25 January 2010 - 11:31 PM, said:

Ok, switching to a Gamelon kill is fine by me. I"ll put it in to PS.

And I'll go ahead and say I healed Thyr.

Agreement from Shin. They haven't submitted the actions yet though...

[Path-Shaper]

Kalse, on 26 January 2010 - 12:34 AM, said:

Action Change Provisional Kill on Gamelon

Here we go.


Sir Thursday

[Path-Shaper]

Osseric, on 26 January 2010 - 04:50 AM, said:

Ok, change of plans.

Kill Gamelon instead.

Confirmation from the partner. Looks like D'rek's time is nigh.

[Path-Shaper]

Well now Baudin's about to make an absolutely killer mistake.

Hood, on 26 January 2010 - 04:18 AM, said:

ok lets do this
Kill Thyrlann

if he is lynched and is the master of the house but the game doesnt end then
Kill Kalse

If he is lynched and comes up inno

Kill Osseric

hopefully with that i can hit scum or at least narrow it down significantly

[Path-Shaper]

Since it's 4-3 right now, any town lynch will end the game, with plenty of NAs to just hammer that point home.

Mayor is NOT in play today so this is the only chance town has... and they gotta get it right big time, considering Thyr is going to die tonight with the given actions (Game and HP also set to die).

Even if they lynch Mockra or an apprentice, it's going to be 2 v 2 tomorrow with the current actions... that would mean an automatic scum victory, I believe, yes?

In fact, the ONLY way the scum don't win this one, even with a scum lynch, is if Baudin fixes his NA or the killers screw up and change their NAs to hit the same target.

[Path-Shaper]

I take it back after reading the thread, the game is effectively over. Two townies have voted for other townies. It is brainlessly easy for Mockra and his cronies to pick one of those two and add their three votes.

I won't end it yet in case they don't show up, or town suddenly gets smart, but lack of participation has really allowed scum to cruise to victory.

MotM is probably going to be Bent. GK had a great thing going there with his turnaround but didn't capitalize on it and let himself get steamrolled. Bent went from a really shaky position, used the thief very well throughout the game, and led his team to victory.

[Path-Shaper]

Heading to bed... game should end soon as those last 2 votes hit.

This post has been edited by Path-Shaper: 26 January 2010 - 06:13 AM

[Barghast]

If it wasn't for that 48 hour lan I wouldn't have been rushed in the last bit and I would have twigged that Mockra being guarded meant he was scum.

[Path-Shaper]

Thyrllan, on 26 January 2010 - 11:15 AM, said:

if its not too late to change card, id like to find the Guard instead

Mockra, on 26 January 2010 - 01:35 PM, said:

Change that kill Thyrllan ...Osseric is a good target for tomorrow if I need it...
So gaurd Serc, kill Thyrllan

Doesn't really matter here, it's over.

[Osseric]

Path-Shaper, on 20 January 2010 - 11:34 PM, said:

I should probably have been posting more messages to SH - sorry about that (you're doing a great job, PB!). Unfortunately I don't really have time to do it while at work...have to keep the moderating quick .

Anyhow, unless some of ths scum try to steal from the Bomber (they die immediately, by the way) or get targetted by the one remaining Vig shot, I can't see any other ending than them waltzing to victory here. Participation is just too low for the innos to coordinate a lynch properly. There's an awful lot of tools at the innos' disposal - they can use the reticence of the Apprentices to choose the King and Consort cards to trap them for example, or get a Guard right. But they've got to work together to use the information they're all getting properly, and with so little being said, that doesn't look like happening. Particularly if Silchas gets killed off tonight - Alt was the only one who was really pushing for that to happen.

I don't understand the "This will give the scum more information" approach - this game is deliberately set up so that the loss of one inno barely hurts the team at all. Players should be ready and willing to sacrifice themselves for the greater good in the knowledge that whoever is left can take up the mantle of the Roled avenger. Shame that hasn't come to the fore.


Sir Thursday

This.

I kept expecting select reveals to put Kalse and I in a position we'd have to try to squirm out of. I kept thinking of ideas for info that could come out on thread that would put us in handcuffs. In fact, I had at least 2 posts all typed up and then frantically edited them because I realized I would be putting ideas out there that I didn't want anyone to run with! Should've been an inno this game.

[Osseric]

Path-Shaper, on 24 January 2010 - 12:09 AM, said:

Shin and The Dude are practically unlynchable. Shin I think has only been lynched as scum when he was outed by a finder. I think The Dude has never once been lynched in a game of Mafia.

I don't know if Mockra survives today, that seems a bit of a stretch, but when you control 3 out of 7 votes, and Gamelon is already kind of on your side, it's hard to imagine the scum not pulling this one out.

That is correct. The Benses game.

For that matter, I've only been lynched once as an inno, and that was in my very first game. If I'm not NK'd, which actually does happen to me, I'm always around for endgame.

[Peanutbutta]

I was continually shocked by the lack of information being presented, TBH. Players should have been much more willing to share, given the volatile nature of the game.

[Barghast]

Hell why do you think I threw that massive rant when I was nearly lynched.

[DeadHedge]

in my defence was my first game so i had no idea what to expect lol. im just happy i made it to end game lol. buggers killed me on my b'day though lol

[Bent]

Happy B-day dead hedge. I had no idea you were the noob. (Thought it was GK, lol, hence my coaching, well that and I thought he was symping me to death, lol) anyway, great game by you, hope you join us again. I really want to say that Shin was a fantastic symp. The dude wasn't around enough to give me a signal I could grab onto, but end game, he not being around really helped hand us the win. Great job both of you.

[General King]

You did well, but seriously only alt kept his head cool and I was too late in organising you guys into an effective force.

[General King]

Bad habit of mine I can't stick to a first day vote, I will change votes three times at least.

[Bent]

Yeah it was the Vote..REMOVE VOTE! that really had me thinking you were my symp.

[General King]

God that could of got you lynched if people really jumped on to the idea that I was scum.