[Obdigore]

Look at Bwgan go, shes capitulating!

[D'rek]

Obdigore, on Aug 4 2009, 11:57 AM, said:

D'rek, are you going to tell us your thoughts on the other couple of people? OR ARE THEY YOUR PARTNERS?

I did an hour ago. Glad to know that for all your wild accusations and attempts to sound like you're actually serious, you're not even reading the thread.

[Bent]

Shinrei, on Aug 4 2009, 10:59 AM, said:

@ Bent,

Your post of "Shin didn't say I was suspicous while we were chatting" wasn't a defense via casting suspicion?

No. That would be OMGUS, that post was a general observation that up until others brought up the fact that (based on meta) I was playing too softly, you had zero to say about me being suspicious, at least, not enough to speak up while you and I were the only ones around. You being a sheep I find suspicious, but thats not a defense.

[Obdigore]

D'rek, on Aug 4 2009, 11:49 AM, said:

Obdigore, on Aug 4 2009, 11:57 AM, said:

D'rek, are you going to tell us your thoughts on the other couple of people? OR ARE THEY YOUR PARTNERS?

I did an hour ago. Glad to know that for all your wild accusations and attempts to sound like you're actually serious, you're not even reading the thread.

No, you edited your post (after it had been quoted twice, which is a no-no), and from what I could tell, you still failed to include all the people, rather just 7 or 8, which means you are still missing 2 or 3.

[bwgan]

Morgoth, on Aug 4 2009, 10:18 AM, said:

dktorode, on Aug 4 2009, 11:13 AM, said:

is there a mod?


or are we just rolling with it freestyle?

you read the whole thing and built not a single opinion?

edit: wrong post quoted.... you get what I meant

See, it's like this post...now how much of this is a genuine question (leading to the subsequent argument) and how much was meta, built upon a history of which I have no knoweldge...and how much of the argument was genuine? I need to read that exchange again, because it initially, and admittedly out of real time context, struck me as odd.


Edit: Cross post

This post has been edited by bwgan: 04 August 2009 - 05:07 PM

[Bent]

Shinrei, on Aug 4 2009, 11:13 AM, said:

ok, i'm out. I just spent the last 20 minutes reading the same page over and over and I still don't know what it said. My brain is asleep even though I haven't actualy gone to bed yet. I'll leave my vote where it is.

This games start time and zero nights all but guarantees I'll be asleep for every deadline.

Don't like this post either, gives ytou an out to miss lynches and claim you are innocent later.

[Obdigore]

D'rek, on Aug 4 2009, 10:18 AM, said:

Obdigore, on Aug 4 2009, 11:13 AM, said:

D'rek, on Aug 4 2009, 10:09 AM, said:

If you must know Obdi, I went to the bathroom. And no, Morgy did not attend.

Good to know!

The second part.

Although DIBS tells me Morgy does like watersports...

So D'rek, what are your thoughts on people currently? Hmmmm?

You still seem very guiltytastic to me as once everyone on-thread was accusing you you have since toned it down drastically. Then again that could go either way, but I don't trust you.

DiBs is playing smooth, probably hoping to get some votes so he can make a silly reveal. He does that when inno or scum so I don't think it's scummy.

Bent is trying to be the managerial 3rd party to various arguments which allows him to contribute a lot of content without being either of the 2 sides and potentially he can try and steer the arguments well as well. That doesn't work nearly as well as a tactic after day 1, though, so I'm willing to give him the benefit of the doubt for now.

Slick seems extremely fixated on you and hasn't offered much commentary about any other players most of the game, so he needs to diversify or else it can be a tad suspicious. If it weren't day 1 I'd think he was a finder.

Grief I've barely noticed, Shinrei has been getting in content but nothing scummy that I've noticed so I'm happy with him. Bwgan was potentially over-doing the innocence routine, but we'll see when she gets back.

Did I miss anyone?

edits:

Morgy is staying under the radar of all the arguments while still having a presence and his first big noticeable contribution was the bit against Dkt for not having opinions - not something that'll come back and bite Morgy in the butt but enough to get his name out. One of my top candidates for scum.

Dkt exploded from Morgy's first accusations but he's cooled down now. Doesn't seem like he really wants to commit to any accusations/trains, however, and when he does it seems a bit timidly.

Tapper I don't have much of a fix on, can't recall any games where he really made a memorable impact on me (though I am likewise crappy at remembering people from when they were alted). He's using his usual far-too-logical-logic style which is always dangerous.

I'm sorry, you are up to 9. Who is the 10th that you missed? Bwgan I think?

[Bent]

Obdigore, on Aug 4 2009, 01:09 PM, said:

D'rek, on Aug 4 2009, 10:18 AM, said:

Obdigore, on Aug 4 2009, 11:13 AM, said:

D'rek, on Aug 4 2009, 10:09 AM, said:

If you must know Obdi, I went to the bathroom. And no, Morgy did not attend.

Good to know!

The second part.

Although DIBS tells me Morgy does like watersports...

So D'rek, what are your thoughts on people currently? Hmmmm?

You still seem very guiltytastic to me as once everyone on-thread was accusing you you have since toned it down drastically. Then again that could go either way, but I don't trust you.

DiBs is playing smooth, probably hoping to get some votes so he can make a silly reveal. He does that when inno or scum so I don't think it's scummy.

Bent is trying to be the managerial 3rd party to various arguments which allows him to contribute a lot of content without being either of the 2 sides and potentially he can try and steer the arguments well as well. That doesn't work nearly as well as a tactic after day 1, though, so I'm willing to give him the benefit of the doubt for now.

Slick seems extremely fixated on you and hasn't offered much commentary about any other players most of the game, so he needs to diversify or else it can be a tad suspicious. If it weren't day 1 I'd think he was a finder.

Grief I've barely noticed, Shinrei has been getting in content but nothing scummy that I've noticed so I'm happy with him. Bwgan was potentially over-doing the innocence routine, but we'll see when she gets back.

Did I miss anyone?

edits:

Morgy is staying under the radar of all the arguments while still having a presence and his first big noticeable contribution was the bit against Dkt for not having opinions - not something that'll come back and bite Morgy in the butt but enough to get his name out. One of my top candidates for scum.

Dkt exploded from Morgy's first accusations but he's cooled down now. Doesn't seem like he really wants to commit to any accusations/trains, however, and when he does it seems a bit timidly.

Tapper I don't have much of a fix on, can't recall any games where he really made a memorable impact on me (though I am likewise crappy at remembering people from when they were alted). He's using his usual far-too-logical-logic style which is always dangerous.

I'm sorry, you are up to 9. Who is the 10th that you missed? Bwgan I think?

Obi fail, thats 8 people, missing Shin and Bwgan

[bwgan]

Obdi and Bent fail...I am on there...

[Obdigore]

Nope, she had shin under the grief section, right before she did the strikethrough and edit.

Oh crap, read it again and she has Bwgan in there too.

So everyone gets their own paragraph except for Grief, Shin, and Bwgan... why?

[Obdigore]

bwgan, on Aug 4 2009, 12:16 PM, said:

Obdi and Bent fail...I am on there...

C
A
P
I
T
U
L
A
T
E

So miss Bwgan - what do you think of everyone so far?

[bwgan]

Apparently I am overly innocent, which is not a thing either of you can claim...

[D'rek]

Obdigore, on Aug 4 2009, 01:06 PM, said:

D'rek, on Aug 4 2009, 11:49 AM, said:

Obdigore, on Aug 4 2009, 11:57 AM, said:

D'rek, are you going to tell us your thoughts on the other couple of people? OR ARE THEY YOUR PARTNERS?

I did an hour ago. Glad to know that for all your wild accusations and attempts to sound like you're actually serious, you're not even reading the thread.

No, you edited your post (after it had been quoted twice, which is a no-no), and from what I could tell, you still failed to include all the people, rather just 7 or 8, which means you are still missing 2 or 3.

which is also why I had a later post saying that I edited that one 8 posts before to include the 3 people I had missed. You should've read that and gone back and actually read the post before plowing ahead with your baseless, sourceless, factless accusations.

[bwgan]

The more I read the more suspicious I am of you and Bent. Grief and D'rek, I have no handle on at all. Morgy like I said worries me because he isn't worrying me. Shin I think is the same as me and feeling a bit at sea...I dunno perhaps I am doing him a disservice and he is scum playing very quiet, but I don't think so. Dkt, makes me think he had a bad day at work.

Tapper I've already commented on. Slick, like I said last night, was agitated, that was probably because you flew at him like the luny you like to pretend you are. Dibs hasn't had a reason to explode, so I can't see why that has been mentioned really...but again that is probs history of which I am unaware.

At the moment you and Bent are my biggest questions...but if anything he seems to be symping you...and that just strikes me as...well insane tbh!

[Path-Shaper]

It is Day 1. 2 hours remaining.

11 players still alive: Grief, D'rek, Shinrei, Bent, Dkt, Bwgan, Slick, Tapper, Obdi, Morgoth, Dibs

6 votes to lynch. 5 votes to go to night.

2 Votes Obdi (D'rek, Slick)
3 Votes Bent (Dibs, Shin, Tapper)
1 Vote Bwgan (Morgy)
2 Votes Morgy (Bent, Obdi)
1 Vote DiBs (DKT)

Players not voted: Grief, Bwgan

[Bent]

bwgan, on Aug 4 2009, 01:17 PM, said:

Apparently I am overly innocent, which is not a thing either of you can claim...

nah, I can claim it, in fact its me not flipping out like Obi did that makes everyone suspicious, add to that the fact that I haven't flipped out with 3 votes and the suspicion increases, I understand really, when I play scum I usually play like this, but I am resigned to the fact that my flipping out hurts my team, and so Im not gonna get pissed, Im gonna make my stance be known and the rest of you can do what you want with the info, ignore it, follow it though, whatever.

[bwgan]

Obdi...why are you trying to make me vote Morgy when you know that if you do that I won't, unless that is what you want me to think...?

[Bent]

bwgan, on Aug 4 2009, 01:25 PM, said:

The more I read the more suspicious I am of you and Bent. Grief and D'rek, I have no handle on at all. Morgy like I said worries me because he isn't worrying me. Shin I think is the same as me and feeling a bit at sea...I dunno perhaps I am doing him a disservice and he is scum playing very quiet, but I don't think so. Dkt, makes me think he had a bad day at work.

Tapper I've already commented on. Slick, like I said last night, was agitated, that was probably because you flew at him like the luny you like to pretend you are. Dibs hasn't had a reason to explode, so I can't see why that has been mentioned really...but again that is probs history of which I am unaware.

At the moment you and Bent are my biggest questions...but if anything he seems to be symping you...and that just strikes me as...well insane tbh!

Yeah, I can see that too, but obi is Obi and I'd hate to waste a lynch on him.

[bwgan]

Now Bent you really are worrying me...being all fatalistic at my making a joke....

[bwgan]

Bent, on Aug 4 2009, 06:27 PM, said:

bwgan, on Aug 4 2009, 01:25 PM, said:

The more I read the more suspicious I am of you and Bent. Grief and D'rek, I have no handle on at all. Morgy like I said worries me because he isn't worrying me. Shin I think is the same as me and feeling a bit at sea...I dunno perhaps I am doing him a disservice and he is scum playing very quiet, but I don't think so. Dkt, makes me think he had a bad day at work.

Tapper I've already commented on. Slick, like I said last night, was agitated, that was probably because you flew at him like the luny you like to pretend you are. Dibs hasn't had a reason to explode, so I can't see why that has been mentioned really...but again that is probs history of which I am unaware.

At the moment you and Bent are my biggest questions...but if anything he seems to be symping you...and that just strikes me as...well insane tbh!

Yeah, I can see that too, but obi is Obi and I'd hate to waste a lynch on him.

But is that what he is counting on?