Kessobahn, on Jun 4 2009, 11:17 PM, said:
Ack, I'm late! Well, sorta...by that I mean, Ack! I wasn't first! So...whats up ya'll? I think we should lynch
vote Fener
cuz he thinks he's clever. Who's with me?
EDIT: BB code fail.
This is the first and only post of Kesso's until the end of day 2. He votes for me.
Kessobahn, on Jun 5 2009, 05:36 PM, said:
I agree with you Sil, I want to see Fener lynched as well. But there's no real reason for it...but then the reasons to lynch you are no less circumstantial...kinda stupid...I suppose I'm willing to hammer, but Fener is still my first choice for being a cocky bastard.
Sorry for my epic absence, almost as soon as I posted my ISP's server went down and then I didn't have time to post this morning.
Then there's a yada yada Fener should be lynched for no reason I can name post.
Kessobahn, on Jun 5 2009, 06:20 PM, said:
Awww, fuck it. Connection is still giving me grief, so I might as well hammer now and hope I can still see the thread later.
remove vote
vote Fener
EDIT: I'm an overtired moron who said the wrong name and crossposted with the actual hammer anyways...maybe I'll step off for a while. Play some games...grow a brain
And he points out again that he votes for me, though he never removed his original vote.
This is his contribution day 1. Strangely fixated I'd say.
Liosan, on Jun 6 2009, 05:59 AM, said:
well, it would seem the night was at least eventful, judging from the scene
since PB's apparently not a cultist, and there's no other ideas out there, I say we go with his biggest suspect:
vote Fener
Then, the very beginning of day 2, Liosan in his first post of the day votes for me. His reason is ridiculously poor to say the least and very much an odd way to start the day.
Ruse, on Jun 6 2009, 06:15 PM, said:
Fener, on Jun 6 2009, 02:59 PM, said:
*snort*, that makes no sense in a merc game, Ruse.
No, I'd say my favoured target for today's lynch is Korlat as I'm quite confident he's got a power role, and I'd rather not have those around
*snort* back at you. You're confident he has a power role, like you were confident about Sil being obsessed with the king of hell.
Fener, on Jun 6 2009, 03:56 PM, said:
D'riss, on Jun 6 2009, 04:34 PM, said:
@ Fener - what makes you so sure he has a power role?
@ Tellan - I can understand your reasoning, but HP (it's obvious enough who is behind the alt) is always away over weekends. I dont see how who is behind alt has anything to the role they might have. We definitely shouldnt forget about him though.
First because of his posting.
In an inno vs evil game, the killers quite often post summaries etc to be seen to contribute and be visible while at the same time not having any impact on the game that can lead back to them. Korlat's extensive descriptions of the books were in essence the same thing. As a power role it's important that you stay alive in order to keep your faction strong, and a way to accomplish that is to hide in plain sight, like I believe Korlat was trying to do.
Then, when I brought this up his reaction said quite a bit I think. Ergo, my suspicion, if not perhaps confirmed, was at least strengthened quite a bit.
so, to get some action going
korlat
To quote someone very wise...oh, that would be you Fener - that makes no sense in a merc game.
But to throw your own argument back to you. The one who keeps on about a role must be a power player...no? I should be smelling bacon, but all I smell is something fishy.
Vote Fener
Ruse does the same, though her reasons are, if still misguided, then at least based on something.
Kessobahn, on Jun 7 2009, 03:50 AM, said:
So you're thinking Fener and Korlat may be related cult? Interesting...I'm off to bed and don't suspect I'll be back until post-deadline, so with that last revelation, I might as well leave a
vote for Fener
And, Ruse, I'm sorry if I was wrong to insinuate that you were accusing Fener of strawmanning, that's just what it seemed like to me.
Lo and behold, Kessobahn votes for me. If Bent can be tunnelvisioned, Kesso is obsessed with getting me lynched. He's yet to provide a reason. Any excuse is good enough to jump onto a vote on me.
Then we move to day 3.
Kessobahn, on Jun 8 2009, 04:46 PM, said:
Fener, on Jun 8 2009, 03:12 AM, said:
Emurlahn, on Jun 8 2009, 08:43 AM, said:
WTF Hetan is reading the game!
It is true, I am Hetan. Beneath this rugged, manly and sexy exterior beats the heart of your divine empress
You think pig-men are sexy? *shudder's violently*
Gamelon, on Jun 8 2009, 09:32 AM, said:
Rashan, on Jun 8 2009, 07:12 AM, said:
I'm here and caught up, gotta head to work, but i'll be back in half an hour or so
Vote Fener
Because if you weren't cult before, theres a really good chance you are now.
Seriously? How does that provide any information? If Fener's telling the truth, his CF will say heshette tribesman or whatever and we won't even know if he's recruited.
If he's telling the truth then there's no harm in lynching him. Certainly it gets rid of a huge distraction. If he's lying, and i think he is, then you have to ask, who has the greatest motivation to lie? Well, the cult recruiter, the cult leader (may be the same, but we don't know for sure), or a killing role. A helpful role would be easy to reveal, as would a useless role, and so when people are pressured we wind up with a lot of both. I think Fener is using his superior knowledge of the books to pick out an obscure name that would have no ability and is using it as a smoke screen. Its working. And its a distraction to finding the real cult.
Also, at (?Meanas?) whoever said Fener would be an awful target for recruit, look at people's reluctance to vote him. All of today, he's only got two votes, and day's been dragging on for a while. Its like a lynch time out creates a PI. Nobody wants to finish the job. I for one call bullshit on the reveal and cast my vote.
vote Fener.
This is a particularly charming piece of rationale. I must be cult because I only have a few days and we're several hours into the day. As if Kesso needed a reason to vote for me in the first place.
This is what I think. I think Kesso is part of the cult. His only contribution day 1 was a vote for me. He recruited Liosan or Ruse, whom followed his lead and continued on what could easily be seen as a form of signaling. In that regard I'm thinkin Ruse is a better candidate than Liosan for the recruit. He tried to make up a reason for the vote whereas Liosan didn't even try and as such is less suspicious in my opinion.
For some reason, Kesso has decided that I am a threat. I don't know why exactly. Or perhaps he simply thought a safe place to be was to throw himself at a single player and just stay there. Little chance of antagonizing many people that way, unless you hit a leader but that's unlikely in the end. His arguments were piss poor, yet people started following his lead. With Liosan's attempt to get things going, Ruse saw the chance to follow her new master and with Kesso, one could be sure to have a sizeable enough voting block. This is a merc game. A lynch mob forms frightfully fast. There's not much of a nudge required.
Alternatively, a cult is pretty fragile early with only one player, so a symp could be part of the faction. If so, Liosan fits the bill perfectly I'd say.
In the end, my vote goes to
Kessobahn
Help
