[Ampelas]

Emurlahn, on May 10 2009, 08:22 AM, said:

I should point out that we are down to 12 players with a maximum of 5 scum, by my estimation. If Galain is anxious enough to pull a trick like this, he must think they're getting near the finish line.

I know, I forced him to reveal, then he is thinking he can use it to speed lynch someone. The only real case there is on you is that supposed find. I'm not buying it. If Galain comes up inno we'll have to lynch you of course.

[Emurlahn]

Unfortunately, I'm going to have to head out in about 5 minutes, and won't be back for 6-7 hours. Horrendous timing, as per usual .

[Omtose]

Wow, Inigo (or whatever) is a big name to claim for yourself. If you're lying, that's a ballsy fucking move.

My vote is staying on for now, because I want to see what Galain says... but whichever of you goes, we know which one will be next if it comes up inno.

The football is just about to start, so I'll be back at half time.

[Emurlahn]

Ampelas, on May 10 2009, 01:25 PM, said:

Emurlahn, on May 10 2009, 08:22 AM, said:

I should point out that we are down to 12 players with a maximum of 5 scum, by my estimation. If Galain is anxious enough to pull a trick like this, he must think they're getting near the finish line.

I know, I forced him to reveal, then he is thinking he can use it to speed lynch someone. The only real case there is on you is that supposed find. I'm not buying it. If Galain comes up inno we'll have to lynch you of course.

Oh, I understand completely. I'll go with no complaints if he comes up inno, really can't blame you if that's the case. But he's definitely lying, so I'm pretty damn confident he'll come up killer. Symps don't have the same desire for self-preservation that the killers do.

[Ampelas]

Omtose, on May 10 2009, 08:27 AM, said:

Wow, Inigo (or whatever) is a big name to claim for yourself. If you're lying, that's a ballsy fucking move.

My vote is staying on for now, because I want to see what Galain says... but whichever of you goes, we know which one will be next if it comes up inno.

The football is just about to start, so I'll be back at half time.

If he is lying I think we can expect a counter reveal on that name. let me point out that Galain haven't claimed a name at all. I think a scum would hesitate before claiming a fake name, since the chance of counter reveal is great, especially on a name like Montoya. As I said I think I am more inclined to believe emur than Galain.

[Emurlahn]

And now I'm gone.

[Ampelas]

I am definitely interested in what Serc has to say about all this. It will be telling if we're on the right track.

[Korvalain]

Your guys thinking is backwards. You lynch the evil find firstly, then you lynch the fake reveal. That way you don't get a (must have been symp) from the other guy. That way you don't lynch your finder. And that way you know if the reveal was true or not.

[Ampelas]

Korvalain, on May 10 2009, 07:33 AM, said:

Your guys thinking is backwards. You lynch the evil find firstly, then you lynch the fake reveal. That way you don't get a (must have been symp) from the other guy. That way you don't lynch your finder. And that way you know if the reveal was true or not.

You're not making any sense, who do you think we should lynch?

[Korvalain]

But, if he has a vig.....

Okvote emurlahn

I think you should shoot Serc in the face. But if not him, then Rashan or Mockra would be ok.

[Korvalain]

Ampelas, on May 10 2009, 08:34 AM, said:

Korvalain, on May 10 2009, 07:33 AM, said:

Your guys thinking is backwards. You lynch the evil find firstly, then you lynch the fake reveal. That way you don't get a (must have been symp) from the other guy. That way you don't lynch your finder. And that way you know if the reveal was true or not.

You're not making any sense, who do you think we should lynch?

I was thinking out loud. typical play demands you lynch Emur first. (note:) he belives there are 5 scum left, so his intrest in getting a real finder lynched ids important, but not as important as the fact that if hes right and we have 12 people right now, and lynch wrong, the game is over. But he claimed a huge name, and the finder got a name instead of scum, so meh.

[Galain]

Emurlahn, on May 10 2009, 02:59 PM, said:

I am NOT Vizzini. That finder reveal was utter bullshit, designed to keep him around for another night. And when he wriggled out of the vig he decided he should use it to his advantage. Look at the way he tried to stop the vig from being used by trying to hammer before Ampelas got a chance. There is no way in hell that he is telling the truth.

Here's a reveal for you. My name is Inigo Montoya. It would be rather poetic if Galain was Count Rugen, wouldn't it? Night 2 I vigged Shadow, because I had gotten it into my head that he was probably scum. Seems I was mistaken then, but I'm not mistaken in the slightest this time. Galain is scum, and you guys should get rid of him ASAP.

Vote Galain

I'm Rezzik, and my partner is Inigo, and he sure as hell aint you

[Ampelas]

Korvalain, on May 10 2009, 07:36 AM, said:

But, if he has a vig.....

Okvote emurlahn

I think you should shoot Serc in the face. But if not him, then Rashan or Mockra would be ok.

Are you drunk? He can't shoot anyone if we lynch him. You're not thinking straight, we have to assume one of them is lying, and I am inclined to believe it's Galain that is lying. If we lynch Emur and galain is scum, we get an NK. If we lynch Galain and Emur is scum, we get an NK. It's the same, we just have to lynch the one guy that we think are lying.

gawd the stupidity these days...

[Ampelas]

Galain, on May 10 2009, 07:40 AM, said:

Emurlahn, on May 10 2009, 02:59 PM, said:

I am NOT Vizzini. That finder reveal was utter bullshit, designed to keep him around for another night. And when he wriggled out of the vig he decided he should use it to his advantage. Look at the way he tried to stop the vig from being used by trying to hammer before Ampelas got a chance. There is no way in hell that he is telling the truth.

Here's a reveal for you. My name is Inigo Montoya. It would be rather poetic if Galain was Count Rugen, wouldn't it? Night 2 I vigged Shadow, because I had gotten it into my head that he was probably scum. Seems I was mistaken then, but I'm not mistaken in the slightest this time. Galain is scum, and you guys should get rid of him ASAP.

Vote Galain

I'm Rezzik, and my partner is Inigo, and he sure as hell aint you

Hum, okay would it be bad to ask your partner to reveal - we have to cover all our bases here - that you say your partner is Rezzik doesn't prove anything you know. We need another reveal so we can cover all our bases. It seems there's only 1 killer scum left anyway.

[Korvalain]

Ampelas, on May 10 2009, 08:40 AM, said:

Korvalain, on May 10 2009, 07:36 AM, said:

But, if he has a vig.....

Okvote emurlahn

I think you should shoot Serc in the face. But if not him, then Rashan or Mockra would be ok.

Are you drunk? He can't shoot anyone if we lynch him. You're not thinking straight, we have to assume one of them is lying, and I am inclined to believe it's Galain that is lying. If we lynch Emur and galain is scum, we get an NK. If we lynch Galain and Emur is scum, we get an NK. It's the same, we just have to lynch the one guy that we think are lying.

gawd the stupidity these days...

a little. and galain re-claims. so there you go. a vig isn't worth a finder.

[Gamelon]

korv - your telling him to use his vig as you lynch him?

ok i have a solution.

we lynch ano, and you vig someone random, and tonight i guard galain. if he is a finder he will still get a find as he claims his partner is out there somewhere.

i have guarded ano the last two nights and the night kills went from 2 then three down to one.

i am fessik, didnt check spelling and i can guard one player a night. this was my reason for voting ano yesterday, i guarded him again, and again our night kills went down.

vote anomandaris

i didnt want to reveal as i am not sure we had solo killers, and had planned on guarding nao again tonight.

i will guard galain tonight instead.

[Ampelas]

Look guys, if Galain is telling the truth, and Emur is scum, that means there's only 1 killer left, right? That means he and his partner can reveal happily since it doesn't matter, we'll basically win if Emur is scum and we lynch him. On the other hand if Galain is lying, he don't want his partner to reveal since he is lying and either he doesn't have a partner or his partner is scum and will get in the cross hairs if we lynch Emur and uncover the lie.

There's an easy way to prove Galain is telling the truth - let the partner reveal. That is all.

Edit: fucking cross post!

This post has been edited by Ampelas: 10 May 2009 - 12:48 PM

[Gamelon]

Galain, on May 10 2009, 01:40 PM, said:

Emurlahn, on May 10 2009, 02:59 PM, said:

I am NOT Vizzini. That finder reveal was utter bullshit, designed to keep him around for another night. And when he wriggled out of the vig he decided he should use it to his advantage. Look at the way he tried to stop the vig from being used by trying to hammer before Ampelas got a chance. There is no way in hell that he is telling the truth.

Here's a reveal for you. My name is Inigo Montoya. It would be rather poetic if Galain was Count Rugen, wouldn't it? Night 2 I vigged Shadow, because I had gotten it into my head that he was probably scum. Seems I was mistaken then, but I'm not mistaken in the slightest this time. Galain is scum, and you guys should get rid of him ASAP.

Vote Galain

I'm Rezzik, and my partner is Inigo, and he sure as hell aint you

remove vote

vote galain

i am FEZZIK. not rezzik, hahaha bad reveal

[Anomandaris]

Boy did I log on at the right time. Gamelon is lying. I am innocent and I can prove it. So it looks like we have our scum cornered.

[Gamelon]

Ampelas, on May 10 2009, 01:47 PM, said:

Look guys, if Galain is telling the truth, and Emur is scum, that means there's only 1 killer left, right? That means he and his partner can reveal happily since it doesn't matter, we'll basically win if Emur is scum and we lynch him. On the other hand if Galain is lying, he don't want his partner to reveal since he is lying and either he doesn't have a partner or his partner is scum and will get in the cross hairs if we lynch Emur and uncover the lie.

There's an easy way to prove Galain is telling the truth - let the partner reveal. That is all.

galain is lying, i am fezzik, aka andre the giant, he even spelt the reveal wrong. and he cant claim i am scum because he already said i was proven inno by his reveal