[D'riss]

Telas, on Mar 10 2009, 10:47 PM, said:

hey, we're only considering our options.

I'm pretty sure I outlined my desire to lynch off korlat clearly enough.

From the way he played tonight, I have no problem voting him again. I don't think it was a slip at all any mnore

[Telas]

fuck it
vote Korlat

i'm gonna be around till deadline (another 40 mins), so i'll switch to hammer if it's really necessary

but this what my gut's been telling me all day
granted, my gut feelings are generally way off, but it's still day 1..

[Silanah]

D'riss, on Mar 11 2009, 02:46 AM, said:

Oh you back stabbing little fucks


I go to do some laundry and this is what i find when I get back



I wasn't going to even vote for you Silanah.


thank you by the way for last second making a case

Vote Silanah

Figured I'd give you something to respond to if you wanted, sorry I couldn't produce that earlier. Survival instincts kicking into gear. Plus, you have made the scummiest moves I've seen today, so I figure it's worth fighting to stay alive...

[Fener]

I think that puts Silanah at L-1. I don't believe he is scum since I don't think he has acted anything like how a killer would, especially by putting himself out there, and if he was a symp, then we must conclude that Korlat is his master since I don't believe that a symp would gain anything from fake symping anyone.
Therefore, since I think he is inno, I cannot in good faith put a vote on him.

There was a good point about D'riss going from asking if it was a reveal by Korlat to being convinced that it was one within one or two posts. This could be explained by him making a slip in possibly outing a finder and then realising that an inno would not do that, so he had to jump to a conclusion that Korlat was fake-revealing or being a dumbass to try and make himself less suspicious in his role of drawing attention to that sentence. Due to this, I am leaning towards a vote on D'riss.

[Silanah]

Telas, on Mar 11 2009, 02:51 AM, said:

fuck it
vote Korlat

i'm gonna be around till deadline (another 40 mins), so i'll switch to hammer if it's really necessary

but this what my gut's been telling me all day
granted, my gut feelings are generally way off, but it's still day 1..

Much as I'd like to see anyone other than me lynched right now, I've set my stall out on Korlat being innocent, so I shall not be supporting you on that one. Man am I going to be annoyed if I get to SH and find out he's scum, the bastard.

[Silanah]

Fener, on Mar 11 2009, 02:56 AM, said:

I think that puts Silanah at L-1. I don't believe he is scum since I don't think he has acted anything like how a killer would, especially by putting himself out there, and if he was a symp, then we must conclude that Korlat is his master since I don't believe that a symp would gain anything from fake symping anyone.
Therefore, since I think he is inno, I cannot in good faith put a vote on him.

There was a good point about D'riss going from asking if it was a reveal by Korlat to being convinced that it was one within one or two posts. This could be explained by him making a slip in possibly outing a finder and then realising that an inno would not do that, so he had to jump to a conclusion that Korlat was fake-revealing or being a dumbass to try and make himself less suspicious in his role of drawing attention to that sentence. Due to this, I am leaning towards a vote on D'riss.

L-1 already? I thought it was 9 for a lynch? We've still got some time, would appreciate someone removing their vote so I can get a few more minutes of life in case a saviour appears from out of nowhere...

[Fener]

Right, I do feel that D'riss is our best lynch candidate today, (see reasons above)

so Vote D'riss

[Telas]

yeah, you're on L-1, but the only one voting for you who's still here is D'riss...
unless it's one of the 2 lurkers

[Fener]

Silanah, on Mar 11 2009, 02:58 AM, said:

Fener, on Mar 11 2009, 02:56 AM, said:

I think that puts Silanah at L-1. I don't believe he is scum since I don't think he has acted anything like how a killer would, especially by putting himself out there, and if he was a symp, then we must conclude that Korlat is his master since I don't believe that a symp would gain anything from fake symping anyone.
Therefore, since I think he is inno, I cannot in good faith put a vote on him.

There was a good point about D'riss going from asking if it was a reveal by Korlat to being convinced that it was one within one or two posts. This could be explained by him making a slip in possibly outing a finder and then realising that an inno would not do that, so he had to jump to a conclusion that Korlat was fake-revealing or being a dumbass to try and make himself less suspicious in his role of drawing attention to that sentence. Due to this, I am leaning towards a vote on D'riss.

L-1 already? I thought it was 9 for a lynch? We've still got some time, would appreciate someone removing their vote so I can get a few more minutes of life in case a saviour appears from out of nowhere...

Yeah, I had you at 5 before 3 people dropped their votes on you, Ano, D'riss and I can't remember the 3rd.

[Telas]

Fener, on Mar 10 2009, 10:00 PM, said:

Silanah, on Mar 11 2009, 02:58 AM, said:

Fener, on Mar 11 2009, 02:56 AM, said:

I think that puts Silanah at L-1. I don't believe he is scum since I don't think he has acted anything like how a killer would, especially by putting himself out there, and if he was a symp, then we must conclude that Korlat is his master since I don't believe that a symp would gain anything from fake symping anyone.
Therefore, since I think he is inno, I cannot in good faith put a vote on him.

There was a good point about D'riss going from asking if it was a reveal by Korlat to being convinced that it was one within one or two posts. This could be explained by him making a slip in possibly outing a finder and then realising that an inno would not do that, so he had to jump to a conclusion that Korlat was fake-revealing or being a dumbass to try and make himself less suspicious in his role of drawing attention to that sentence. Due to this, I am leaning towards a vote on D'riss.

L-1 already? I thought it was 9 for a lynch? We've still got some time, would appreciate someone removing their vote so I can get a few more minutes of life in case a saviour appears from out of nowhere...

Yeah, I had you at 5 before 3 people dropped their votes on you, Ano, D'riss and I can't remember the 3rd.

Serc who's high on Nyquil

[Fener]

Come on lurkers, identify yourselves!

[Telas]

it's probably Emu and Kas

[D'riss]

Fener, on Mar 10 2009, 10:56 PM, said:

I think that puts Silanah at L-1. I don't believe he is scum since I don't think he has acted anything like how a killer would, especially by putting himself out there, and if he was a symp, then we must conclude that Korlat is his master since I don't believe that a symp would gain anything from fake symping anyone.
Therefore, since I think he is inno, I cannot in good faith put a vote on him.

There was a good point about D'riss going from asking if it was a reveal by Korlat to being convinced that it was one within one or two posts. This could be explained by him making a slip in possibly outing a finder and then realising that an inno would not do that, so he had to jump to a conclusion that Korlat was fake-revealing or being a dumbass to try and make himself less suspicious in his role of drawing attention to that sentence. Due to this, I am leaning towards a vote on D'riss.

what he didn't say in the case is that there were thirteen posts between those two

[D'riss]

Fener you REALLY need to back and read that whole section.

[Serc]

Can we get a vote count?

I'm starting to get some uncomfortable doubts about voting for Silanah, thanks to Fener. But I'm leaving my vote, because his arguments are ones I've already thought of myself - it's just slightly more convincing to hear them from someone else. D'riss, after all, was the one who started pushing for Korlat ...

This post has been edited by Serc: 11 March 2009 - 03:11 AM

[Silanah]

Serc, on Mar 11 2009, 03:10 AM, said:

Can we get a vote count?

I'm starting to get some uncomfortable doubts about voting for Silanah, thanks to Serc. But I'm leaving my vote, because his arguments are ones I've already thought of myself - it's just slightly more convincing to hear them from someone else. D'riss, after all, was the one who started pushing for Korlat ...

Bit of an identity crisis there?

D'riss said:

Fener you REALLY need to back and read that whole section.

What specifically are you referring to? There wasn't anything, as far as I can tell, that would have warranted a change of opinions. Korlat made a few posts, sure, but they were in reference to another argument that was going on at the time - he never properly addressed your point except by accident.

[Fener]

D'riss, on Mar 11 2009, 03:10 AM, said:

Fener you REALLY need to back and read that whole section.

I did, and yes there are like 10 posts in between them, but which of the ones in between would you say that convinced you? The one saying night Korlat, or the 5 or so which revolved round him quoting the wrong post? I didn't see anything myself that would have caused such a change in stance so I stand by my case.

Edit: Xpost with Silanah

This post has been edited by Fener: 11 March 2009 - 03:14 AM

[D'riss]

Silanah, on Mar 10 2009, 11:12 PM, said:

Serc, on Mar 11 2009, 03:10 AM, said:

Can we get a vote count?

I'm starting to get some uncomfortable doubts about voting for Silanah, thanks to Serc. But I'm leaving my vote, because his arguments are ones I've already thought of myself - it's just slightly more convincing to hear them from someone else. D'riss, after all, was the one who started pushing for Korlat ...

Bit of an identity crisis there?

D'riss said:

Fener you REALLY need to back and read that whole section.

What specifically are you referring to? There wasn't anything, as far as I can tell, that would have warranted a change of opinions. Korlat made a few posts, sure, but they were in reference to another argument that was going on at the time - he never properly addressed your point except by accident.

As is with a well made case, it's miss leading. Your intentionly miss leading people with this. I waited then things got weird.

Korlat did the smartest thing he could do. He said some wierd comments then fled.

There have been a few times when I stepped on my dick playing a killer, and when called on it was stupid and tried to talk my way out of it. Failed BIG time.

[D'riss]

Fener, on Mar 10 2009, 11:13 PM, said:

D'riss, on Mar 11 2009, 03:10 AM, said:

Fener you REALLY need to back and read that whole section.

I did, and yes there are like 10 posts in between them, but which of the ones in between would you say that convinced you? The one saying night Korlat, or the 5 or so which revolved round him quoting the wrong post? I didn't see anything myself that would have caused such a change in stance so I stand by my case.

Edit: Xpost with Silanah

It was close to tweenty minutes between posts so you cant say I just jumped.

[Telas]

well, we got 10 mins to go

should I hammer or not?

i'm having doubts on whether it's worth it...