Well, quite of a start we got there
I'll make a little recap, this in no way summarizes what is out there, just what I believe is significant:
Korlat - joke about being finder. If done on purpose, serves no good I can see except throwing a bucket of shit on a working fan, and at the end he will be the first to pay IMO. I would still not vote him off today, though.
D'riss - pointed out the joke as a serious reveal. To be honest, in my read-through I missed it, because it was in the middle of an argument which I thought was stretching. Still, you can't assume the killers would "miss it" since killers generally analyse the thread to death for symp and roled clues, so I don't think he did any damage pointing it out. Still, he could be a symp, after all like I said scum tend to read the thread more closely.
Anomander - I agree that he did over-react to minimal pressure. After all, he throws a buch of suspicions around, then says he'll marinate on it before voting. He then behaves like his vote is a death penalty for the poor voted, which is a bit of a bulls-t argument for not voting. Hesitation to vote is scummy in my eyes, since it makes a point, and bring light to the one who votes (specially if there's a valid reason given)
Silanah- My current vote, see my vote post for the explanation.
Gamelon - I didn't forget his initial comment-on-anyone post, I have seen this before by Morgoth to signal his masters when he was a symp (in Yellow's suicide bomber game). According to that, his masters would be most probably Omtose and D'riss.
All this to say that I would vote for any of those (to a lesser extent, Korlat) today. Of course, this might all be crap, but that's what I see so far.
This post has been edited by Galayn Lord: 10 March 2009 - 12:13 PM