[Galain]

Mentalist, on Feb 23 2009, 04:46 PM, said:

Galain, on Feb 23 2009, 11:43 AM, said:

ahh fuck its night??? wtf how did that happen!!!

A ninja 'sploded

now your insulting me with both the mod and your own account you cheeky git!

[Silanah]

Do you think the last ninja can explode... If he explodes, and takes say 2 inno's with him, doesn't that mean we win?

[Silanah]

but yeah, I guess if we don't lynch a ninja tomorrow we are right fucked. cause thats an extra NK and an inno lynch. Its do or die time.

[Mentalist]

Galain, on Feb 23 2009, 11:48 AM, said:

Mentalist, on Feb 23 2009, 04:46 PM, said:

Galain, on Feb 23 2009, 11:43 AM, said:

ahh fuck its night??? wtf how did that happen!!!

A ninja 'sploded

now your insulting me with both the mod and your own account you cheeky git!

nope
Kurt's using the Aqua skin for PS.
so I've been modding the entire game from my account.

[Fener]

Silanah, on Feb 23 2009, 11:48 AM, said:

Do you think the last ninja can explode... If he explodes, and takes say 2 inno's with him, doesn't that mean we win?

Silanah, if it's as I suspect, he gets a double day vig since

Serc had a day vig
Telas had a double day vig with a suicide
Omtose had a single day vig with a suicide

Either that or he just gets the nightly NK, not sure.

[Hood's Path]

Sorry for my slightly nonsensical posts, I was playing from my phone, which kept doing weird things. I'm back at home now, so I should be able to play properly. Who knows, with a little luck we might have this game wrapped up in a couple of hours.

[Galain]

Fener, on Feb 23 2009, 04:51 PM, said:

Silanah, on Feb 23 2009, 11:48 AM, said:

Do you think the last ninja can explode... If he explodes, and takes say 2 inno's with him, doesn't that mean we win?

Silanah, if it's as I suspect, he gets a double day vig since

Serc had a day vig
Telas had a double day vig with a suicide
Omtose had a single day vig with a suicide

Either that or he just gets the nightly NK, not sure.

it just hit me that you used a day vig aswell and thats why you are pi, coupled with the fact that the ninjas didnt kill anyone night two if you were the master you may of just withheld.

[Mentalist]

still waiting for several actions....

[Galain]

everyone was on, whats the hold up, bloody provisionals people!!! us bored folk need entertained and titilated!!!

[Silanah]

Well I think it's been narrowed down, I think it's D'riss or HP. With an outside shot of Fener being the final Ninja. In my eyes Galain, GL are CI and Emur is PI.

thats just where I stand.

[Fener]

FUCK!

I had a long-ass case on Galain ready and somehow lost the firefox tab. Because I don't want to go through and reread through all his posts again, here's the important parts:

He makes a really weak case against Serc while the confirmed ninja is away, knowing none will join the train out of consideration for his absence. Kessobahn goes on to kill Serc.
He claimed he was going to vig GL (which I think was a wifom threat to NK--if he claims he'll kill GL and Korlat dies instead, he's presumed innocent?)
GL does not die that night; Galain claims he was blocked/bp'd (I'm thinking he actually killed Korlat instead).
Galain sees an opportunity for a non-ninja lynch and attacks D'riss.
Ano reveals finder and that Omtose is ninja, Galain immediately distances (see the pattern?)
He's flip-flopped on GL all game; he claimed to have vigged him, asks for his opnion.
Then, he switches an hour later and calls GL a ninja. Wtf?
Claims he knew Silanah is first mate before last night and attacked GL regardless, implying he is also a finder vig...just like Ano. There haven't been duplicate roles so far, and if you are finder why didn't you investigate GL (whom you've had suspicions about from day 1 or 2) during night #2, when I protected everyon?
I call him out on some slip-ups, he immediately accuses me of being the ninja master and withholding? a kill, or something like that?

Slightly out-of-order there.

Would've been a much better case if my firefox tab didn't randomly disappear.

[Fener]

Silanah, on Feb 23 2009, 12:28 PM, said:

Well I think it's been narrowed down, I think it's D'riss or HP. With an outside shot of Fener being the final Ninja. In my eyes Galain, GL are CI and Emur is PI.

thats just where I stand.

How is Galain CI?

[Emurlahn]

Fener, just fyi - he claimed he was given the alt-name of the first mate in his role pm, not that he was a finder.

[Silanah]

He outed me as First Mate.. why would a ninja know that?

[Galain]

Fener, on Feb 23 2009, 05:28 PM, said:

FUCK!

I had a long-ass case on Galain ready and somehow lost the firefox tab. Because I don't want to go through and reread through all his posts again, here's the important parts:

He makes a really weak case against Serc while the confirmed ninja is away, knowing none will join the train out of consideration for his absence. Kessobahn goes on to kill Serc.
He claimed he was going to vig GL (which I think was a wifom threat to NK--if he claims he'll kill GL and Korlat dies instead, he's presumed innocent?)
GL does not die that night; Galain claims he was blocked/bp'd (I'm thinking he actually killed Korlat instead).
Galain sees an opportunity for a non-ninja lynch and attacks D'riss.
Ano reveals finder and that Omtose is ninja, Galain immediately distances (see the pattern?)
He's flip-flopped on GL all game; he claimed to have vigged him, asks for his opnion.
Then, he switches an hour later and calls GL a ninja. Wtf?
Claims he knew Silanah is first mate before last night and attacked GL regardless, implying he is also a finder vig...just like Ano. There haven't been duplicate roles so far, and if you are finder why didn't you investigate GL (whom you've had suspicions about from day 1 or 2) during night #2, when I protected everyon?
I call him out on some slip-ups, he immediately accuses me of being the ninja master and withholding? a kill, or something like that?

Slightly out-of-order there.

Would've been a much better case if my firefox tab didn't randomly disappear.

ok, big problem with your case. Minei snt the only vig not to work, soemone blocked ano too or driss also was bp. and i didnt claim finder. I have said this a few times, silanah's name was in my pm, my role pm, i am the helmsman, and embarrasingly like gazing at the fucker in the moonlight according to kurt the funny fucker. so that is why i aint killing the bugger and thats why if you look back i have never once said anything about him being suspicious.

every ninja has had a day vig ability that we know of. You had a day vig ability. you said you could stop them killing at night, and lo and behold they didnt kill at night. you said the ninja master has two day vigs, i think you used one on ruse when you realised there was a cult in play!!

i am voting you int hte morning!

[Fener]

Emurlahn, on Feb 23 2009, 12:31 PM, said:

Fener, just fyi - he claimed he was given the alt-name of the first mate in his role pm, not that he was a finder.

If I was a finder, I'd be learning names via PM too. It's easy to lie.

Silanah, on Feb 23 2009, 12:31 PM, said:

He outed me as First Mate.. why would a ninja know that?

Nothing precludes ninjas (i.e. the ninjas' symps) from being finders as well. Assuming they can communicate (a likely possibility imo) he could very easily know.

[Hood's Path]

Fener, on Feb 23 2009, 07:28 PM, said:

FUCK!

I had a long-ass case on Galain ready and somehow lost the firefox tab. Because I don't want to go through and reread through all his posts again, here's the important parts:

He makes a really weak case against Serc while the confirmed ninja is away, knowing none will join the train out of consideration for his absence. Kessobahn goes on to kill Serc.
He claimed he was going to vig GL (which I think was a wifom threat to NK--if he claims he'll kill GL and Korlat dies instead, he's presumed innocent?)
GL does not die that night; Galain claims he was blocked/bp'd (I'm thinking he actually killed Korlat instead).
Galain sees an opportunity for a non-ninja lynch and attacks D'riss.
Ano reveals finder and that Omtose is ninja, Galain immediately distances (see the pattern?)
He's flip-flopped on GL all game; he claimed to have vigged him, asks for his opnion.
Then, he switches an hour later and calls GL a ninja. Wtf?
Claims he knew Silanah is first mate before last night and attacked GL regardless, implying he is also a finder vig...just like Ano. There haven't been duplicate roles so far, and if you are finder why didn't you investigate GL (whom you've had suspicions about from day 1 or 2) during night #2, when I protected everyon?
I call him out on some slip-ups, he immediately accuses me of being the ninja master and withholding? a kill, or something like that?

Slightly out-of-order there.

Would've been a much better case if my firefox tab didn't randomly disappear.

Some good points there and I admit he has been acting a little suspicious. The only problem is that galain revealed silanah correctly (or at least he hasnt died and noone else counter-claimed). I have no idea how a ninja would have acquired the info (although that's really irrelevant considering the game so far) or what a ninja would have gained by revealing it. It helped narrow the list down to two people, one of whom was actually a ninja, I'm fairly confident Driss is too.

[Fener]

Galain, on Feb 23 2009, 12:33 PM, said:

Fener, on Feb 23 2009, 05:28 PM, said:

FUCK!

I had a long-ass case on Galain ready and somehow lost the firefox tab. Because I don't want to go through and reread through all his posts again, here's the important parts:

He makes a really weak case against Serc while the confirmed ninja is away, knowing none will join the train out of consideration for his absence. Kessobahn goes on to kill Serc.
He claimed he was going to vig GL (which I think was a wifom threat to NK--if he claims he'll kill GL and Korlat dies instead, he's presumed innocent?)
GL does not die that night; Galain claims he was blocked/bp'd (I'm thinking he actually killed Korlat instead).
Galain sees an opportunity for a non-ninja lynch and attacks D'riss.
Ano reveals finder and that Omtose is ninja, Galain immediately distances (see the pattern?)
He's flip-flopped on GL all game; he claimed to have vigged him, asks for his opnion.
Then, he switches an hour later and calls GL a ninja. Wtf?
Claims he knew Silanah is first mate before last night and attacked GL regardless, implying he is also a finder vig...just like Ano. There haven't been duplicate roles so far, and if you are finder why didn't you investigate GL (whom you've had suspicions about from day 1 or 2) during night #2, when I protected everyon?
I call him out on some slip-ups, he immediately accuses me of being the ninja master and withholding? a kill, or something like that?

Slightly out-of-order there.

Would've been a much better case if my firefox tab didn't randomly disappear.

ok, big problem with your case. Minei snt the only vig not to work, soemone blocked ano too or driss also was bp. and i didnt claim finder. I have said this a few times, silanah's name was in my pm, my role pm, i am the helmsman, and embarrasingly like gazing at the fucker in the moonlight according to kurt the funny fucker. so that is why i aint killing the bugger and thats why if you look back i have never once said anything about him being suspicious.

every ninja has had a day vig ability that we know of. You had a day vig ability. you said you could stop them killing at night, and lo and behold they didnt kill at night. you said the ninja master has two day vigs, i think you used one on ruse when you realised there was a cult in play!!

i am voting you int hte morning!

I had a blanket BP; if anyone was dumb enough to use a night vig they could back me up.
Also, I highly doubt you knew Silanah's identity via role PM--for me, it told me I was always chillin' with the serving wench...I never knew it was Tennes the whole time (Kurt you bastard).

[Fener]

Hood's Path, on Feb 23 2009, 12:36 PM, said:

Fener, on Feb 23 2009, 07:28 PM, said:

FUCK!

I had a long-ass case on Galain ready and somehow lost the firefox tab. Because I don't want to go through and reread through all his posts again, here's the important parts:

He makes a really weak case against Serc while the confirmed ninja is away, knowing none will join the train out of consideration for his absence. Kessobahn goes on to kill Serc.
He claimed he was going to vig GL (which I think was a wifom threat to NK--if he claims he'll kill GL and Korlat dies instead, he's presumed innocent?)
GL does not die that night; Galain claims he was blocked/bp'd (I'm thinking he actually killed Korlat instead).
Galain sees an opportunity for a non-ninja lynch and attacks D'riss.
Ano reveals finder and that Omtose is ninja, Galain immediately distances (see the pattern?)
He's flip-flopped on GL all game; he claimed to have vigged him, asks for his opnion.
Then, he switches an hour later and calls GL a ninja. Wtf?
Claims he knew Silanah is first mate before last night and attacked GL regardless, implying he is also a finder vig...just like Ano. There haven't been duplicate roles so far, and if you are finder why didn't you investigate GL (whom you've had suspicions about from day 1 or 2) during night #2, when I protected everyon?
I call him out on some slip-ups, he immediately accuses me of being the ninja master and withholding? a kill, or something like that?

Slightly out-of-order there.

Would've been a much better case if my firefox tab didn't randomly disappear.

Some good points there and I admit he has been acting a little suspicious. The only problem is that galain revealed silanah correctly (or at least he hasnt died and noone else counter-claimed). I have no idea how a ninja would have acquired the info (although that's really irrelevant considering the game so far) or what a ninja would have gained by revealing it. It helped narrow the list down to two people, one of whom was actually a ninja, I'm fairly confident Driss is too.

There are 4 ninjas, HP. It's extremely likely at least 1 was a finder and could figure that out.

[Galain]

Fener, on Feb 23 2009, 05:33 PM, said:

Emurlahn, on Feb 23 2009, 12:31 PM, said:

Fener, just fyi - he claimed he was given the alt-name of the first mate in his role pm, not that he was a finder.

If I was a finder, I'd be learning names via PM too. It's easy to lie.

Silanah, on Feb 23 2009, 12:31 PM, said:

He outed me as First Mate.. why would a ninja know that?

Nothing precludes ninjas (i.e. the ninjas' symps) from being finders as well. Assuming they can communicate (a likely possibility imo) he could very easily know.

Oh wait i can stop night kills pi me!! your case is shit.