[Omtose]

Yarr. Ya heard me earlier suggestion. Who be the one what pulled a day vig kill so early in the game with no real knowledge o' who be a ninja or pirate? Seems like a waste o' life without even discussing their decision with the group first *drinks rum*. If the person be wasting lives like that I be voting fer 'em. Even if they are a pirate, its just safer for everyone's skin to stop the gold grubbin' scallywags. I be needin' a recap of actions if anyone wouldn't mind, I can't go trudging through the tome o' nonsense again.

[Fener]

Besides, the last time I voted night they be usin' my own peg leg to sodomize me arse! It's a joke! arr.

'Tis a painful memory, I'll be gone awhile purging it from me mind.

[Fener]

Omtose, on Feb 19 2009, 10:27 AM, said:

Yarr. Ya heard me earlier suggestion. Who be the one what pulled a day vig kill so early in the game with no real knowledge o' who be a ninja or pirate? Seems like a waste o' life without even discussing their decision with the group first *drinks rum*. If the person be wasting lives like that I be voting fer 'em. Even if they are a pirate, its just safer for everyone's skin to stop the gold grubbin' scallywags. I be needin' a recap of actions if anyone wouldn't mind, I can't go trudging through the tome o' nonsense again.

Arr well

Mockra claimed to vig Kaschan
Serc claimed to vig Gamelon

I think Gamelon died first.

[Galayn Lord]

Fener, on Feb 19 2009, 04:28 PM, said:

Omtose, on Feb 19 2009, 10:27 AM, said:

Yarr. Ya heard me earlier suggestion. Who be the one what pulled a day vig kill so early in the game with no real knowledge o' who be a ninja or pirate? Seems like a waste o' life without even discussing their decision with the group first *drinks rum*. If the person be wasting lives like that I be voting fer 'em. Even if they are a pirate, its just safer for everyone's skin to stop the gold grubbin' scallywags. I be needin' a recap of actions if anyone wouldn't mind, I can't go trudging through the tome o' nonsense again.

Arr well

Mockra claimed to vig Kaschan
Serc claimed to vig Gamelon

I think Gamelon died first.

I can't remember reading any reasons - did they give any?

[Mockra]

Omtose, on Feb 19 2009, 04:27 PM, said:

Yarr. Ya heard me earlier suggestion. Who be the one what pulled a day vig kill so early in the game with no real knowledge o' who be a ninja or pirate? Seems like a waste o' life without even discussing their decision with the group first *drinks rum*. If the person be wasting lives like that I be voting fer 'em. Even if they are a pirate, its just safer for everyone's skin to stop the gold grubbin' scallywags. I be needin' a recap of actions if anyone wouldn't mind, I can't go trudging through the tome o' nonsense again.

Makes the suspect pool smaller. Also, if we have a load of day-vigs, and if any of the other roles are nearly as powered as mine, then I can guarantee you the Ninjas probably have some form of defence against vigs.
Also, I'm not going to reveal as Day Vig until I've actually used my vig, and the only reason I'm revealing that I'm using my other power is because after it, I'm essentially RI, with no ability and a slightly annoying RP enforcement.
Also, I used my vig because I didn't like Kaschan, and I didn't feel like leaving it on the offchance I got lynched today. The vig isn't my most useful power. My other one is, which I want to stay alive till I have time to utilize it. IE tonight.

[Mockra]

Galayn Lord, on Feb 19 2009, 04:30 PM, said:

Fener, on Feb 19 2009, 04:28 PM, said:

Omtose, on Feb 19 2009, 10:27 AM, said:

Yarr. Ya heard me earlier suggestion. Who be the one what pulled a day vig kill so early in the game with no real knowledge o' who be a ninja or pirate? Seems like a waste o' life without even discussing their decision with the group first *drinks rum*. If the person be wasting lives like that I be voting fer 'em. Even if they are a pirate, its just safer for everyone's skin to stop the gold grubbin' scallywags. I be needin' a recap of actions if anyone wouldn't mind, I can't go trudging through the tome o' nonsense again.

Arr well

Mockra claimed to vig Kaschan
Serc claimed to vig Gamelon

I think Gamelon died first.

I can't remember reading any reasons - did they give any?

Reasons in my above post, and yes, that was the timing of the events.

[Omtose]

Well then, my vote is fer either Mockra or Serc, since the two o' them be dangerous to the group either way. *hic* Mockra is be makin' more of an effort to expouse fact from the lot o' ya, but his facts could be taken as either truths or false assumptions meant to persuade you away from him. Serc 'as offered less infermation but 'as made less assumptions as well. Arr. It be a difficult decision to make...Any opinions anyone? Make yer case you two! *gets drunk some more yadda yadda*

(Cross post with Mockra)

Yarr, Mockra's case be made fairly well. I still don't know if'n I want ter see what he does tonight though. Serc has a few more hours to argue his case. Otherwise I'm making him walk the plank! Arr!

Vote Serc

This post has been edited by Omtose: 19 February 2009 - 03:37 PM

[Galayn Lord]

Mockra, on Feb 19 2009, 04:32 PM, said:

Omtose, on Feb 19 2009, 04:27 PM, said:

Yarr. Ya heard me earlier suggestion. Who be the one what pulled a day vig kill so early in the game with no real knowledge o' who be a ninja or pirate? Seems like a waste o' life without even discussing their decision with the group first *drinks rum*. If the person be wasting lives like that I be voting fer 'em. Even if they are a pirate, its just safer for everyone's skin to stop the gold grubbin' scallywags. I be needin' a recap of actions if anyone wouldn't mind, I can't go trudging through the tome o' nonsense again.

Makes the suspect pool smaller. Also, if we have a load of day-vigs, and if any of the other roles are nearly as powered as mine, then I can guarantee you the Ninjas probably have some form of defence against vigs.
Also, I'm not going to reveal as Day Vig until I've actually used my vig, and the only reason I'm revealing that I'm using my other power is because after it, I'm essentially RI, with no ability and a slightly annoying RP enforcement.
Also, I used my vig because I didn't like Kaschan, and I didn't feel like leaving it on the offchance I got lynched today. The vig isn't my most useful power. My other one is, which I want to stay alive till I have time to utilize it. IE tonight.

Ah, I am inclined to believe you, actually, mostly because it's complicated enough and because it fits with what I know myself.

The timing of the other day vig worries me though - two day vigs is a bit much - has Serc explained?

[Tennes]

Mockra, on Feb 19 2009, 03:32 PM, said:

Makes the suspect pool smaller.

Mockra, that's great. The suspect pool is smaller, we're in such a better position now.

[Mockra]

Serc? Aye. He did in JA because of something he said about RP, which makes, in my mind, and knowing who Serc is, a twisted amount of sense.

All in all, my eye is still on him, but I see him as being slightly less likely to be a Ninja than the major suspect pool, for reasons of the reveal (His confidence in claiming. A Ninja just wouldn't do that. And also his power fits in with what I know, too.)

[Mockra]

Tennes, on Feb 19 2009, 04:39 PM, said:

Mockra, on Feb 19 2009, 03:32 PM, said:

Makes the suspect pool smaller.

Mockra, that's great. The suspect pool is smaller, we're in such a better position now.

Well, now we have more serious talk as opposed to an abundance of RP fun.

[Galayn Lord]

Aye and I am thinking that no ninja would be as stupid as claiming a vig on day one.

Edit: even though I am reluctant to take into account your meta argument.

This post has been edited by Galayn Lord: 19 February 2009 - 03:44 PM

[Mockra]

We also have information about mechanics, reveals, etc to go on, as well as two CFs.

[Mockra]

Galayn Lord, on Feb 19 2009, 04:43 PM, said:

Aye and I am thinking that no ninja would be as stupid as claiming a vig on day one.

A budding Weasel-esque player would. But that's not really Serc at all. He plays loud, and usually a little inconsistently. A bit like Telas and Lisheo.

[Telas]

Didn't serc say that he vigged Gam cause Gam said he had to RP the whole game?
Im just wondering if this is after of before someone else said they only had to do it for a day(rashan?) in which case it could've made gamelon sound fake, I suppose.
If not, it doesn't really make sense. Not sure about serc.

[Telas]

Mockra, on Feb 19 2009, 03:44 PM, said:

Galayn Lord, on Feb 19 2009, 04:43 PM, said:

Aye and I am thinking that no ninja would be as stupid as claiming a vig on day one.

A budding Weasel-esque player would. But that's not really Serc at all. He plays loud, and usually a little inconsistently. A bit like Telas and Lisheo.

I resent that.

[Galayn Lord]

Mockra, on Feb 19 2009, 04:44 PM, said:

Galayn Lord, on Feb 19 2009, 04:43 PM, said:

Aye and I am thinking that no ninja would be as stupid as claiming a vig on day one.

A budding Weasel-esque player would. But that's not really Serc at all. He plays loud, and usually a little inconsistently. A bit like Telas and Lisheo.

How sure are you? It would be really bad if you misread.

[Mockra]

I'm not sure about him either, his reasoning is strange, but I can't see him claiming a Day Kill he didn't commit. Especially as a Ninja. The original could just counterclaim him, and then I expect someone here has a role which would identify Serc as a Ninja, or we'd just lynch him anyway.

[Telas]

I also know who serc is.
I'm pretty certain about it anyhow.

As for what he's like, he claimed finder when inno and not a finder, because gut feeling. Lucky he was right too.

If that helps.

[Galayn Lord]

On that note though, I am inclined to believe that the people pushing up most dirt is more likely to be pirates than ninjas in this situation. We don't have that many weasel players.