[Path-Shaper]

Well I am off for several hours so if JA or someone else wants to check in as Path-shaper and keep an eye on things please do so.

Thread is pretty dead at the moment anyway.

[Jump Around]

I'm here, I'll keep an eye.

[Jump Around]

I'm not sure what The Man Who is playing at there, but I don't like it too much.

"I didn't play so well until now, and don't plan to start so just take me out"? What's the point then? Some players had tough early games because it was their first one, like Hinter and Tehol, and now they're playing well, I don't see the problem.

Plus, in any game you have good moments and bad moments, that's the concept of "playing".

Anyways, he didn't send any official request to PS, if he does I'm not sure what to do. We HAVE to play some very basic, non-CF games, it's incredible that everybody is so frozen right now. Lost, that's OK, we're lost most of the time even with the CF, but to the point of just giving up?

[Jump Around]

Galain, on Jan 30 2009, 01:35 PM, said:

OK, I might have been a bit heavy handed there. I was saying I wouldn't go for a modkill for inactivity because that would be too dodgy, due to the obvious potential to cheat. Therefore I was suggesting I do something else modkillworthy like being majorly abusive or something. I'm feeling a little less heated now, and no longer think this is the right course of action.

Apologies, just under a bit of stress. In RL. But I probably shouldn't have mentioned that.

Much better

[alt146]

The Dude, on Jan 30 2009, 01:32 AM, said:

Path-Shaper, on Jan 29 2009, 03:16 PM, said:

baudin, on Jan 29 2009, 11:11 PM, said:

The Dude, on Dec 2 2008, 07:20 PM, said:

Fine-

Vote Thyrllan

Sil if you are scum I hate you and you will be on all of my lists for all time. Well played sir if you are.

just a reminder, of our glorious victory....

..........
..............
..................

Ment you bettter really really really hope I am never a vig. Because you sir shall die!!

That is if I can ever alt guess you.. it always takes me 3-4 days.

Hehe, he's the only person I can ever spot (expect for the time I got JA off his first post, cos noone but him and DK change text size). Anyway, you're looking for:

trains
labs
being up late at night
references to stuff happening in/relating to eastern europe
Although I am constantly amazed by the old-hands's ability to alt-guess each other based on the most subtle things. I might get Lish, Grief and Ment by the end of the game, and then I'm playing well.

This post has been edited by alt146: 30 January 2009 - 12:27 PM

[Morgoth]

ment is obvious right away . No one else writes post like he does

As for the others, you just get a feeling of their posts after a while. I can rarely show exactly what convinces me of who's behind a specific alt.. Much like how I can rarely pinpoint what exactly makes me suspicious of someone. It's got a lot more to do with a feeling than concrete signs, at least for me.

[Morgoth]

@Ment - Pah! Poppycock! If you'd been a good boy and saved me you'd have cf for another day and I would've been able to make a case on DiBs. You should learn to do what I'm thinking god damn you.

I had it all figured out and you and Yellow just refused to play nice. If I'd been saved I was going to make a case on Liosan and push some more on the kaschan fener connection.

If I'd been recruited I was going to make a case on DiBs, and a gut case on Kaschan, pushing the Liosan case at the front. I figured i'd be considered a likely cult at that point which would hopefully invalidate my case on Kaschan in the eyes of the others without me seeming to suddenly back down from him.

I was so pleased, and then I died! pah!

[Mentalist]

alt146, on Jan 30 2009, 07:25 AM, said:

The Dude, on Jan 30 2009, 01:32 AM, said:

Path-Shaper, on Jan 29 2009, 03:16 PM, said:

baudin, on Jan 29 2009, 11:11 PM, said:

The Dude, on Dec 2 2008, 07:20 PM, said:

Fine-

Vote Thyrllan

Sil if you are scum I hate you and you will be on all of my lists for all time. Well played sir if you are.

just a reminder, of our glorious victory....

..........
..............
..................

Ment you bettter really really really hope I am never a vig. Because you sir shall die!!

That is if I can ever alt guess you.. it always takes me 3-4 days.

Hehe, he's the only person I can ever spot (expect for the time I got JA off his first post, cos noone but him and DK change text size). Anyway, you're looking for:

trains
labs
being up late at night
references to stuff happening in/relating to eastern europe
Although I am constantly amazed by the old-hands's ability to alt-guess each other based on the most subtle things. I might get Lish, Grief and Ment by the end of the game, and then I'm playing well.

yes, that's when I'm bored and don't try to hide my alt
there are games when i go for several days without mentioning an of that stuff
I got you without even trying in my first PM i wrote "the one with a broken router's probably alt",

edit: though I must say, I was sloppy with alt guesses this game, wasn't even sure about Bent and Venge for most of the game.
I think Itrusted Meanas because I thought either he or Shadow were Venge. and Venge hasn't been evil in a decent amount of time.

This post has been edited by Mentalist: 30 January 2009 - 01:29 PM

[Mentalist]

Morgoth, on Jan 30 2009, 07:41 AM, said:

@Ment - Pah! Poppycock! If you'd been a good boy and saved me you'd have cf for another day and I would've been able to make a case on DiBs. You should learn to do what I'm thinking god damn you.

I had it all figured out and you and Yellow just refused to play nice. If I'd been saved I was going to make a case on Liosan and push some more on the kaschan fener connection.

If I'd been recruited I was going to make a case on DiBs, and a gut case on Kaschan, pushing the Liosan case at the front. I figured i'd be considered a likely cult at that point which would hopefully invalidate my case on Kaschan in the eyes of the others without me seeming to suddenly back down from him.

I was so pleased, and then I died! pah!

well, no, I disagee
if you lived, everyone would assume you were recruited and push for your lynch, DiBs especially.
i'd have to reveal to say you weren't.
and then D'riss would have counter-revealed.

oh, and not to mention kas had both sets of psychics look at him and find him undead that night.....
and we all saw what happened then...

[Mentalist]

for the record, does anyone know of a n easy way to extricate graphs out of PDFs?

[Mentalist]

hey, dkt's startig to think!

he's gonna look at who Shadow suspected... too bad he never got to Liosan....

[Sir Thursday]

Oooh, Rashan suspects Meanas as the master and Ruse as the symp! Liosan is still untouchable though .


Sir Thursday

[Mentalist]

if I were to fathom a guess, Bent's fianlly caught on to Meanas = Venge, and it's a reflexive thing from the I WIN thread days....

it's good that he's looking at at least A scum... better than the rest

I still feel it'll be Galain for the lynch though

Sil dies at night.. and rashan will probably be the next NK.

[Path-Shaper]

I think Bent has finally figured out Meanas is scum. He's been playing pretty scummy just no one has looked at him hard. But since his hammer vote people are looking at him now. Liosan has stayed out of those sorts of games and kept his nose clean.

Bad news for the innos, DKT is off his game. Loveingly entitled "Hey Bitch"

Ruse said:

So I feel that shadow was killed because it was implied that he had two votes.
If this is true then the killers must be VERY sure he is not a symp.

So one of the people that shadow has finger banged in the past must be a killer.

Galain
Silanah
Rashan
D'iss (having a hard time believing a killer would counter reveal like that so not sp much D'riss)


those are my suspects

So he suspects 4 Innos. Its practically everyone left outside the killing team sheesh. Bent and DKT are both experienced and should be able to pull it through for the innos, but Liosan even absent is getting nothing looked at him at all.

[Mentalist]

note to self: in all future games, mention all suspicions, no matter how vague, on thread

both me and Shadow had Liosan warning bells ringing at the backs of our heads... but we never actually wrote it down for all to see.

Well, I DID write ti down, sorta, as a possible master for D'riss, but no one's even looked at that....

[Mentalist]

from thread

D'riss, on Jan 30 2009, 09:56 AM, said:

I'm pretty certain that after Mockra's outstanding job of muddying the waters anything I say will be pretty much ignored from now on. I've presented my defence, it was completely ignored, so I guess I'm just hanging around waiting to see the end game.

Still, fun while it lasted

so now, I'M the one muddied the waters. not the person who tried to be accomodating saying "well then, I guess there were two witches, that makes sense given the NK pattern", but the one who muddied the water... bah

silly noobs.....

[Giles]

Well I did write down my Meanas suspicions many times but look how well they were listened too...

[Mentalist]

baudin, on Jan 30 2009, 10:02 AM, said:

Well I did write down my Meanas suspicions many times but look how well they were listened too...

you don't count
you were an obvious creature from Day 2,

RE: no CF games
i'm thinking of an 11 person-mini, mostly roled, based on a game "Blood Omen"
it would be interesting to run that without a CF, but then i'd have to explain all the roles in thread...

This post has been edited by Mentalist: 30 January 2009 - 03:29 PM

[Stalker]

When we were talking about alt guessing earlier... I had Ment pinned after our Iliad talk, and let Dibs know heh.

[Path-Shaper]

A few posts, from Meanas as well, I am shocked he's been so quiet this game.

Quote

Well bloody hell. I wish that I had been on when Benrash still had his vote on cause then I could have driven it home and be damded the consequences. Bloody hell. I need to make a fucking huge case on someone, only I don't know if I am going to have enough fucking time. I missed work yesterday and I have a lot of shit to catch up on. Plus who should I make the bloody case on. I am thinking either Omtose or Rashan. Taking a day off has made me start to lose my touch. I feel the game is starting to slip away and I don't like that feeling at all. Not after all of the work that we have done to get here. Sigh.... Still it is good to see that Liosan hasn't made anyones list so far. All I need to do is make it through the next couple of days alive and then we will be home free. Bloody hell I need to take Bent out or at least get Dibs to see how big of a threat he is.

More Meanas

Quote

Ohhh I am so close to just letting Ruse and Benrash slug it out by themselves for most of the day. Either one of them could go. I think that I have to make a case on Rashan so that liosan can see that Rashan is the other double voter. It is so obvious if you look at the last couple of pages. For instance why do you need to remove your vote when a person is at l-4 and say there is a double voter out there who could put galain at l-1 unless your a double voter yourself. Stupid mistake. Liosan should be able to pick it up easily..... Fuck...

And a nice change, a little D'riss a little sore with te dual witch reveal...

Quote

I'm highly unlikely to be around at the weekend. Seems I'm being pretty much ignored now though, after Mentalists brilliant campaign of misinformation (or not??) just before he was lynched I bow down to a mafia master