[Path-Shaper]

Mockra, on Dec 4 2008, 10:40 PM, said:

So what you are telling me is that in this game, i wont ever know which team i am on? Actually thats not true, i could try and lynch you, then i can tell by your name whether i am good or bad laugh.gif

DiBs finally figures it out, lol.

[Path-Shaper]

Sir Ruse

Quote

Well, the first Day and Night really didn't go well for us, did it?

Having looked over some stuff, I'm becoming more and more suspicious about Omtose and Gamelon. I'm thinking maybe Omtose's early attack on Korlat was distancing, because it really is a horrendous case otherwise. So lump Korlat in with them as well.

I'm going to say Korlat, Omtose, Gamelon and one other are the scum. Which means that the reveal from Mockra was probably only half truth - I think he's now scum after guarding Gamelon. No need to reveal otherwise...although I guess there's a little pressure on Gamelon at the moment, maybe he thought if he could clear someone it would help...seems to obvious for him though.


Sir Thursday/Ruse

Gamelon

Quote

Fener is Grief

[Path-Shaper]

Path-Shaper, on Dec 4 2008, 11:13 PM, said:

Mockra, on Dec 4 2008, 10:40 PM, said:

So what you are telling me is that in this game, i wont ever know which team i am on? Actually thats not true, i could try and lynch you, then i can tell by your name whether i am good or bad laugh.gif

DiBs finally figures it out, lol.

About bloody time. I figured we did everything but draw him a bloody map...

Vengeance

[Path-Shaper]

Gamelon

Quote

Quote

Quote

Its Grief.

It's a Pig. Fallen War-God Pig If you wanna get technical wink.gif

I'll take that as a yes smile.gif woot, my alt guessing is improving, even if my playing is not biggrin.gif

[Path-Shaper]

Who else is here??

Vengeance

[Path-Shaper]

Path-Shaper, on Dec 5 2008, 12:20 AM, said:

Path-Shaper, on Dec 4 2008, 11:13 PM, said:

Mockra, on Dec 4 2008, 10:40 PM, said:

So what you are telling me is that in this game, i wont ever know which team i am on? Actually thats not true, i could try and lynch you, then i can tell by your name whether i am good or bad laugh.gif

DiBs finally figures it out, lol.

About bloody time. I figured we did everything but draw him a bloody map...

Vengeance

And then Emur calls bullshit on DiBs not knowing his alignment. LOL. Looks like DiBs might be in spoilers tomorrow rooting for team evil.

Oh, this is alt...

[Path-Shaper]

I cant wait to see lish's reply when we tell him tomorrow that he's suddenly a symp. Lolzor.

This post has been edited by Path-Shaper: 04 December 2008 - 11:31 PM

[Path-Shaper]

Anyway, I'm off to bed now, unless this crossposts with something. Enjoy the rest of your whatever time it is now in Vengyland.

[Silencer]

I just don't get into spoilers much, sorry guys. Not as fun.

Fener, on Dec 5 2008, 12:28 PM, said:

Ruse, on Dec 4 2008, 03:12 PM, said:

Fener, on Dec 4 2008, 10:46 PM, said:

wow, tough decisions on whether to leave Mockra alive. He could be a valuable source of info and helpful if he tags evil... or a major source of disinformation if he manages to tag one of the 2-3 remaining goods. Hard telling. With only 2-3 roled left (admittedly that number is a guesstimate) We might want to let him have a night and see what happens. Not sure why you would reveal though... now you are a prime lynch and NK target

I agree with this for the most part. After initially saying I accepted the reveal (despite misreading it ), I got down to considering the possibility that he might have lied about the result from his vote. Here are the possible scenarios I came up with.


1) He's telling the truth. Implication: Gamelon is not a Ghostbuster, but is innocent (that's assuming that only hitting a Ghostbuster would entail hitting someone 'good').

2) He's actually good now because Gamelon was evil. This one doesn't really make sense - if he was good he would probably tell us about Gamelon's evilness, thus giving us the possibility of a lynch. Though he would get NKed unless one of the remaining Ghostbusters has a heal...

3) He's evil, as Gamelon is a GB. This one doesn't really make all that much sense either. If Gamelon is a GB, why clear him? Surely it would make more sense either keep quiet and try and manipulate a lynch (suspicions have already been raised about him, after all, I'm sure it would be possible to put a case together), or to declare Gamelon as evil and himself as good, and ask that he be guarded to prevent NK. Depending on whether he thought he would be believed, he might managed to kill off another GB before attention turns on him.

4) He's evil, he actually guarded a GB and ended up knowing that Gamelon was scum, letting him clear him with a fake reveal today.

Of the 4, I think 2 & 3 can probably be discounted, so it's either 1 or 4. If it were 4, I think we'd see him try and communicate who the GB he guarded was to the other scum somehow, or perhaps try and encourage some lynching action (perhaps he can talk off thread now, I don't know). Not 100% sure of the best way to eliminate/confirm #4, apart from to give him some rope to hang himself with (ie. let him live through the next night and if he doesn't get NKed, grill him mercilessly about it tomorrow). I'm not inclined to jump to the conclusion that he is scummy right now, because if I did it based on the possibility they were scum, I would be voting for everyone.

I say we let him live as he is most likely dead tonight. I just don't see how the killers will let him live. there are only 3-4 evil in all probability. If by chance he does investigate an evil tonight, he comes back and tells us and we lynch. Why would the killers allow this, they already have 2 GB's down. They are in control right now, and the chances of Mockra hitting a good guy and joining team evil is very low. (I think I sound like a symp right now...oh well). I say we make the killers waste their NK on Mockra, they kind of have to unless they are willing to take a huge risk of inno's gaining a find and a guard. Seems an unnecessary risk on their part. What that means for us?? we need to hit scum tonight to even up the score. I don't think a Mockra death will hurt us. Yellow probably threw Slimer in there as a wild card. Able to swing both ways. Like JA. ( I Kid!! I kid!!) So I don't think it would upset the balance.

^The bold is mine, but I do recall me convincing Ment to NK someone based on this word usage last time.

Mafia is fun for me no matter what. It really doesn't matter. Some game types are more fun than others, true - personally, I like cult games, merc games, and mid-TMDI ones - but I can enjoy anything. It's a great little time-waster.

Anyway, I won't be around for a couple of days. So put any admin questions on to Morgo, will ya?

[Path-Shaper]

Will do Silencer...

Later Alt.

Vengeance


Emu/tapper...hehehehe

Quote

Quote

Whoops, hit delete instead of reply. This is alt btw, but you're right, it is a good running gag, so while Yellow's away, just pretend this is from him:

Dont worry, that happens to chicks all the time - it's the main reason guys get laid. God Bless alco-pops.

Alt - in no way condones sexist behaviour or the taking advantage of drunken females wink.gif

Hee hee hee.
Is the entire convo in spoiler heaven?
I could send you the missing parts from my outbox, I had the presence of mind to save them... biggrin.gif

Emur/Tapper, drunk but retaining a love for good gags. And be glad I didn't have a digital cam at hand, or poor Yellow P-S would have been shocked by a pic of my palm tree and coconuts... In which case I'd pity every single one of you but Yellow.

Also, say hello to Lace, i didn't alt guess him this game, which is a first. Pity he got killed, it would be interesting to see how he'd play. And now, I'm going to make myself a coffee even though it is 30 past midnight and my alarm clock will ring at 6.30. Fuck alcohol.

[Path-Shaper]

I don't think that the inno's are out of it yet. I almost would have modkilled dibs for his reveal cause it was practically what he role was. I don't know why they wouldn't lynch him. I mean it is obvious that he could easily count against the good guys. Plus it is mafia doctrine that you get rid of unknown variables. Which Dibs role is an unknown variable. Like a vig they are dangerous to leave around.

Vengeance

[Path-Shaper]

What is it with people and betting their Mafia cards this game. Bent has lost his and now The Dude just bet his. He is right but still. On a side note does the dude have a card?

Also I am against taking cards away based on one game. Bent gets Kell of the game. But he would have to mess up pretty bad in a couple of games to lose his card. But that is just me.

Vengeance

This post has been edited by Path-Shaper: 04 December 2008 - 11:58 PM

[Path-Shaper]

Also did anyone tell Dibs that he was still neutral or was that some stupid guess on his part?


I miss games were symps would fake reveal as a finder and get someone not their master lynched. Those were fun times. But Mass reveals irritate me to no end.

This post has been edited by Path-Shaper: 05 December 2008 - 12:03 AM

[Path-Shaper]

KessoBent

Quote

I think Game is a Ghostbuster. Fuck, I am trying to sound not sympish, but then I posted that don't send Mockra to me WIFOM. Hopefully that keeps them wondering, but if he is a GB then slimer wouldn't work, right? He's not a nobody, fuck. I think I got this right, so I am going to protect Game by fake symping the shit out of him. I think. Fuck. Maybe not. Fuck. My luck Shadow is the last GB and then what, they die we lose. Fuck.

Poor Bent's Card is so toast...ahahahahaha. He is going to protect the soon to be sympish Guard...

[Path-Shaper]

They don't know what to think about Dibs role. Probably cause we haven't had one like it. ( That I can remember anyway) hehehehee

[Path-Shaper]

lol;

Quote

I fail to alt-guess anyone! That sucks! i didn't ghet Lace, for fuck's sake. Haven't spotted dkt, hadn't guessed Morgy = HP, haven't spotted JA, DiBs or Gem, and the last two, I can usually guess quite fast. Is Gem even playing?

Tapper/Emurlahn, confused and worried, not in the least by our main mod, who's been sending me quite explicit messages about dipping his palm tree in a (my?) tropical sea. I'm playing hard to get just to harass him, and despite me being obviously male and quite heterosexual, I must say he's a master of the cliches of sexual innuendo

[Path-Shaper]

last one was Tappelahn
-ment, finally woke up properly 7: 30 PM

[Path-Shaper]

Lisheon:

Quote

I think I may be wrong. Baudin could be Kessobahn, which would be an unusual shift in playing style.

Dead thread is sorta dead. I'm guessing its just me and EmurGoth atm. Or EmurTapper. Or whoever he is

So lets hope for a reply soon, so we can start discussing useful stuff.

and Kessobent:

Quote

Emu -FUCK YOU! that is all

-Ment

[Path-Shaper]

ahahahahahaha

[Silencer]

I think if someone bets their card, they should lose it. Otherwise there is no value to the bet. Sure, it's currently unprecendented, and I'm completely biased...but meh.