[Omtose]

Tennes, on Dec 9 2008, 11:05 AM, said:

At a guess, the GBs equipment only actually works on ghosts, they're not like vigs, more selective, in that they only kill the people their weapons are designed for.

So i am useless in this game then?
my lynch votes wont work?...bah

[Tennes]

If you've got an unrevealed first name that the same, im betting I can figure that one out too.
My point being, guessing it isnt impossible, believe me or not that I didnt see it revealed.

[Kessobahn]

Tennes, on Dec 9 2008, 11:03 AM, said:

I dont "just" want to discredit you.
Its just fucking stupid to consider you all CI.
The killers may well know you're telling the truth. I dont.

Yes, we have to make the best of the situation. That doesnt mean trusting everyone making the claim.
Yes, they're going to hide. But we have to look everywhere. Perhaps it would sew less doubt, if we all ignored you, but if even one of you is scum, that gives that one, who guessed the name, a free ride.
I dont want to lynch any of you. Im willing to trust you for now. But ignoring a section of people entirely is a blatantly bad idea.

Ok, I agree with this 100 percent. Also, I will have to do a re-read, because I am not sure who was the first person to ask for the first letter of the last name, but that person isn't CI, because they where the ones asking the questions, what if I had answered R, they could have still said, yup you are CI. A bit of a gamble there, but a very helpful move if it worked, which it did. Off to see who brought that up.

[Tennes]

Im not saying RIs are useless, but im betting that we're in a worse situation than we think. Yes, its not do or die yet, but if scum has BPs, which frankly, isnt unlikely, given the amount of stuff like that we've seen recently.
If it takes a few attempts to kill gozer, that'll give her a lot of kills, unless our guard is still about

[Omtose]

Tennes, on Dec 9 2008, 11:06 AM, said:

If you've got an unrevealed first name that the same, im betting I can figure that one out too.
My point being, guessing it isnt impossible, believe me or not that I didnt see it revealed.

still waiting for an explanation?

You pulled shmoe out of a hat of names perhaps?

[Tennes]

No, I guessed it from the bits I did read.
Have you all got the same first name, as you mentioned that someone told you the first letter, and its not been revealed, i'll bet i can get that one too.

[Tennes]

Why the fuck are you insisting a name like schmoe is unguessable, with all the stuff flying around? Fuck no. It isnt.

[Kessobahn]

Don't know about BP's. Hey heres an idea, lets lynch a bad guy and find out if it they can be lynched!

[Omtose]

and my first name is Joe...its in the same post that i revealed my second name in.
So stop pretending to have super natural powers and tell me how you came by shmoe?

[Omtose]

Tennes, on Dec 9 2008, 11:10 AM, said:

Why the fuck are you insisting a name like schmoe is unguessable, with all the stuff flying around? Fuck no. It isnt.

Yes it is unguessable, i refuse to belive that off all the names on gods given earth you would pick Schmoe as our second name.
Smith
Soap


You see, in my post i said Average Joe Shmoe....THAT is why you said i would "guess" your second name was Shmoe. You were scared the second name was actually Joe.
I think you are full of shit.

[Omtose]

Tennes, on Dec 9 2008, 11:10 AM, said:

Why the fuck are you insisting a name like schmoe is unguessable, with all the stuff flying around? Fuck no. It isnt.

ok...so you used a hat?
or perhaps you have a baby name book lying around?

All the info you had was the first letter, and there are MANY possible names that we RI's could have been called.
For scum to take that chance and guess that is impossible. In fact that info was given as proof fener knew the name. So he couldnt know it was S unless he knew the name.
Or are you telling me he took a 1/26 shot at it?

puhlease !!!

[Omtose]

Tennes, on Dec 9 2008, 11:09 AM, said:

No, I guessed it from the bits I did read.
Have you all got the same first name, as you mentioned that someone told you the first letter, and its not been revealed, i'll bet i can get that one too.

first letter was Guessed by kessoh already

[Omtose]

HP confirmed there Guesses IIRC...wich for me proves him to be CI aswell.

[Tennes]

Cause "schmoe" isnt used as an average sounding name ever...
Also, why the fuck did you reveal your name?
Fener had said not too.
Not only that, but as you say, there was only an s reveal. Why not just do what the others say. The way you revealed it, made it impossible for anyone else to use the same trick. Isnt that bad, since you want all the RIs to reveal, thus narrowing down the pool to scum and roled ones?

[Omtose]

Sorry for spamming the bordds but i have FUAK ALL internet the whole day and i need my FIX GOD DAMMIT!!!!!!!

[Ruse]

Joe Schmoe was the standard inno name in the last game too, which makes it more likely someone would guess it .

[Tennes]

ROFL!!!
You think im so stupid that I think "Joe" is a second name?
Rofl.

There are about two commonly used "average" names, that I was choosing from, initials JS.

John Smith.
Joe Schmoe.

50/50 chance of getting it right.

I was working on the basis RI would have a "common" name.

An average person is often thought of as a "Joe schmoe", at least on TV , so it isnt a hard guess to make.

[Tennes]

Why the fuck are you trying to get all of you CI'd on the basis that "Joe Schmoe" is an unguessable name. No fucking way that it is.

[Omtose]

Tennes, on Dec 9 2008, 11:19 AM, said:

Cause "schmoe" isnt used as an average sounding name ever...
Also, why the fuck did you reveal your name?
Fener had said not too.
Not only that, but as you say, there was only an s reveal. Why not just do what the others say. The way you revealed it, made it impossible for anyone else to use the same trick. Isnt that bad, since you want all the RIs to reveal, thus narrowing down the pool to scum and roled ones?

I reaveled it as a casual thing before i even knew that they had all done it.
I never said it was my name.

I just said something like "why is everyone jumping at shadows, im just your Average Joe schmoe"

Hoping to get the attention of the other RI's....only to find out they have already been finding other RI's by giving the letters of the name.


Now...Joe shmoe is used as an average sounding name.
BUT so is
Mr smith
John Doe
Average Joe
etc etc

I dont think any killer would have the balls to take a shot in the dark guess. Get it wrong and you get lynched.
I think you read my post and now pretended to "guess" what my second name is.
I think you did this to further discredit us.

I think there is a decent chance you are scum SIR.

My vote stays...i am going home now.
Good night.

[Tennes]

Also, the only thing your reveal served to do was to clear yourself, and let everyone know the name.
For example, Fener hadnt even said what the letter was, he just asked.
But you conviniently told everyone the name, thus making it impossible anyone could use it to clear again. Why do that?

This post has been edited by Tennes: 09 December 2008 - 04:27 PM