[Fener]

Rashan, on Dec 8 2008, 11:11 AM, said:

Fener, on Dec 8 2008, 08:06 PM, said:

Rashan, on Dec 8 2008, 11:04 AM, said:

Fener, on Dec 8 2008, 07:58 PM, said:

Rash you just claimed RI

Whoa, you're one for stating the obvious.

Humor me here. What is the second letter of your last name.

My role pm didn't give me a last name.

remove vote

Vote Rashan

We have 5 RI's all claiming to get the same last name. all have verified in one form or another that they have the same last name. Why are you different? Why would you be the only RI without a last name??

Busted Unless Yellow, did something different for you. In my mind we have to get rid of you now, just to verify. I can't see why he would give 5 RI's the same last name and you be different. I can't see why you would claim RI with no Prompting or pressure if you were a roled inno. I can only assume you are scum that wanted to portray innocence,.

[Tennes]

We've all got the same last name?

Do we all have the same first name too, or are we one big happy family?

[Rashan]

Oh crap, Yellow must be fucking with us. Because my pm clearly states 'goodie'.

[Tennes]

Out of interest Fener, pray tell why you are jumping at anyone who looks not like a RI?
Yes, that could be scum. It could also be GB, and I reckon both will be claiming RI.

[Ruse]

Fener, on Dec 8 2008, 07:18 PM, said:

Rashan, on Dec 8 2008, 11:11 AM, said:

Fener, on Dec 8 2008, 08:06 PM, said:

Rashan, on Dec 8 2008, 11:04 AM, said:

Fener, on Dec 8 2008, 07:58 PM, said:

Rash you just claimed RI

Whoa, you're one for stating the obvious.

Humor me here. What is the second letter of your last name.

My role pm didn't give me a last name.

remove vote

Vote Rashan

We have 5 RI's all claiming to get the same last name. all have verified in one form or another that they have the same last name. Why are you different? Why would you be the only RI without a last name??

Busted Unless Yellow, did something different for you. In my mind we have to get rid of you now, just to verify. I can't see why he would give 5 RI's the same last name and you be different. I can't see why you would claim RI with no Prompting or pressure if you were a roled inno. I can only assume you are scum that wanted to portray innocence,.

I don't think that's the right conclusion to jump to. I think we can assume there are a few inno roles with film names and the like - it wouldn't surprise me if Rashan has a title like "Librarian" or something like that. (I think that's a role in the film, yeah? Going of IMDb as I haven't seen it).

[Rashan]

Oh crap, please don't tell me Fener is looking for the remaining GB's by trying to eliminate RI's? Really not smooth Fener, not smooth at all. You're looking very suspicious as of now.

[Tennes]

Yeah, gotta say I dislike that Feners pushing a lynch for anyone who looks non RI.
Yes, he ahd no prompting, but anyone roled will want to look RI for the killers, thus, the claim.

I reckon you're a possible symp, pulling attention to anyone roled, after all, the scum will know its not them(if they can communicate off thread, which is quite probable).

[Fener]

Tennes, on Dec 8 2008, 11:21 AM, said:

Out of interest Fener, pray tell why you are jumping at anyone who looks not like a RI?
Yes, that could be scum. It could also be GB, and I reckon both will be claiming RI.

Why would you claim RI if you aren't under pressure. Part of the role of an RI is to make the Scum think that you are Roled so that you can draw their votes. Well after the way the game played out, a bunch of RI's were brought to the forefront. This sucks.. but now we have to switch tacts and make due with what we have. Take advantage of our strength (numbers). If Rash was a GB, he wouldn't have claimed he had no last name. I think a GB would have (Hopefully been playing close enough attention to the thread to know that the RI's have last names. Who sometimes feel that they don't need to do really close rereads. Scum. Rash, if you really are RI i'm sorry, blame your death on Yellow, but 5 that have the same last name and you being different... Seems fishy.

Also Tennes, if we need a GB alive to win... we are pretty much screwed anyway. The scum can read the thread as well. At least one of them is paying attention. I had Sil pegged as a GB. Why do you think I looked at him but laid off. He clearly had info on the Gozer/ Gatekeeper dynamic. It made to much sense. But, if we don't need a GB alive to win, this is one way to do it. They already know who the RI's are anyway cause it popped out when Game revealed...like I said we have to deal with it.

[D'riss]

This talk of RI makes me cry. Seriously.

The only ones I find interesting, like I said before, are Tennes and Shadow. They were "outed" last night by our fantastically bright and motivated team mates, yet they survived the night. That, in itself, makes me think they are not roled innos, but scum.

But to look at another angle just in case the scum are dumb or, like I said, have some finder that allowed them to ignore the accusations and focus on the GB Silanah:

I will go and

vote Kaschan

Simply because yesterday he was trying to stall the lynch of Gamelon after finding out he was Dana. He got called for it, then jumped in the train with arguments so ridiculous to explain why he didn't before he was pressured that it can only be bullcrap

Plus, he was boohoo-ing that he's only around when there's nobody, now he's around and everyone is there, and what does he do? vote Mockra for being Slimer, then skips? Not bad in itself, but not super-participative.

[Tennes]

Well, why are you voting for people you think arent RI then, scummy by your own definition, since they are likely roled.
And of course there is pressure to look RI, if you're roled. It stops them killing you.
With luck we dont need a GB alive to win, but I get the feeling we might. Call it gut, but im guessing they can do something very helpful.

[Fener]

Ruse, on Dec 8 2008, 11:26 AM, said:

Fener, on Dec 8 2008, 07:18 PM, said:

Rashan, on Dec 8 2008, 11:11 AM, said:

Fener, on Dec 8 2008, 08:06 PM, said:

Rashan, on Dec 8 2008, 11:04 AM, said:

Fener, on Dec 8 2008, 07:58 PM, said:

Rash you just claimed RI

Whoa, you're one for stating the obvious.

Humor me here. What is the second letter of your last name.

My role pm didn't give me a last name.

remove vote

Vote Rashan

We have 5 RI's all claiming to get the same last name. all have verified in one form or another that they have the same last name. Why are you different? Why would you be the only RI without a last name??

Busted Unless Yellow, did something different for you. In my mind we have to get rid of you now, just to verify. I can't see why he would give 5 RI's the same last name and you be different. I can't see why you would claim RI with no Prompting or pressure if you were a roled inno. I can only assume you are scum that wanted to portray innocence,.

I don't think that's the right conclusion to jump to. I think we can assume there are a few inno roles with film names and the like - it wouldn't surprise me if Rashan has a title like "Librarian" or something like that. (I think that's a role in the film, yeah? Going of IMDb as I haven't seen it).

Fair enough- but my vote stays for now.

@ Tennes, you can say I look suspicious all you want. Make a case.

@Rash, No thats not what I am trying to do. I am looking for inconsistencies in a group of people who I feel could be scum. I listed the group earlier. I'm not trying to out the last GB. But there is no way the last GB is stupid enough to claim RI with all the RI outing that is going on. That would be suicide.

[Tennes]

Well, im guessing the people "outed" survived because they were surer of Sil than us. And id have to agree that its not great that people are doing the outing. Still, damage done now.
I'll go re-read kaschan. Havent re-read much, been busy so far.

[Ruse]

I'm going to have to admit defeat for today guys - I've been trying to review people's posts but I'm just not stringing stuff together at the moment - if there was something there I don't think I'd spot it . I'll hang around with the current discussion, but the excavations through the mounds of posts from the past few days are going to have to wait for some other time, I'm afraid.

[Tennes]

Why would it be suicide. Look how many people have claimed RI. So maybe scum think its one of them, but theyve got lots of people to choose from.
Also, the last one may be relying on the scum thinking itd be stupid. Ruling things out is stupid.

[Rashan]

Really Fener, stop being so daft.

Just think, with your own reasoning, Why would I want to claim RI? Think, dammit! Don't just blurt stuff out before thinking it through. Idiot. Why would I openly go against the set rule of RI having last names? The whole RI thing has been bad for our team. Sowing confusion and possibly getting the scums after me it's what I want, dammit! And now you've screwed up my nice plan.

[D'riss]

Rashan, on Dec 8 2008, 09:43 PM, said:

Really Fener, stop being so daft.

Just think, with your own reasoning, Why would I want to claim RI? Think, dammit! Don't just blurt stuff out before thinking it through. Idiot. Why would I openly go against the set rule of RI having last names? The whole RI thing has been bad for our team. Sowing confusion and possibly getting the scums after me it's what I want, dammit! And now you've screwed up my nice plan.

What? It's not like the scum will fall for the arguments you are scum - at least the killers, normally they know of each other.

If Fener has good points that you ain't RI, and your plan is to sound roled inno, then your plan is working perfectly if you ask me

[D'riss]

Urgh, i feel ass participating to discussions like my last post.

Anyways, I'm off to bed. Will be back soon

[Rashan]

D'riss, on Dec 8 2008, 08:45 PM, said:

What? It's not like the scum will fall for the arguments you are scum - at least the killers, normally they know of each other.

If Fener has good points that you ain't RI, and your plan is to sound roled inno, then your plan is working perfectly if you ask me

You guys are hopeless.

[Tennes]

Not I.

[Fener]

Fuck it, I am out for a while. Rash the logic of your last post baffles me. Scum knows Scum usuallyand if you are inno you have to assume they do.. all you are doing is making yourself sound to be a roled inno. But if you are RI, good job, now the killers will go after you for sure cause you just did a great job of making yourself sound roled. Either I really just fucked things up for the innos, or you are scum. I think you are scum. I'll be back in a few hours.